Vegetarianism in context: a comparative look at plant-based and omnivorous dietary patterns
Introduction
In recent decades, dietary choices have moved beyond personal taste and tradition to become a subject of scientific inquiry, public debate, and, for many, a conscious lifestyle decision. Among these choices, vegetarianism occupies a central and often symbolic position. Yet vegetarianism is not a single, uniform way of eating. It exists along a broad spectrum of plant‑based diets – from occasional meat reducers to strict vegans – and stands in contrast to various omnivorous patterns, including the so‑called Western diet (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
The growing interest in plant‑based eating is driven by multiple motives: health concerns, environmental awareness, animal welfare, and sometimes religious or ethical beliefs (Sandri et al., 2024). At the same time, popular narratives often present vegetarianism as either a clear path to better health or, conversely, as a diet fraught with nutritional risks. The scientific reality, however, is more nuanced. The effects of a vegetarian diet on the human body and on quality of life cannot be understood without comparing it to other dietary patterns that share some of its features (e.g., vegan, flexitarian, pescatarian) as well as to those that differ substantially (e.g., conventional omnivore or Western diets).
This article aims to provide an objective, evidence‑based comparison of the vegetarian diet with other dietary patterns. We will examine how these diets differ in their nutritional composition, their associations with metabolic and cardiovascular markers, their influence on the gut microbiome, and their overall links to health outcomes and longevity. Importantly, we will also discuss the concept of diet quality – showing that not all plant‑based diets are equally beneficial, and that the quality of plant foods matters as much as the exclusion of animal products (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
The information presented here is drawn from recent large‑scale observational studies, meta‑analyses, and systematic reviews, with a focus on research published between 2014 and 2025. We will not provide medical advice or therapeutic recommendations. Instead, our goal is to offer a clear, educational overview for readers interested in the science of nutrition, helping them understand where vegetarianism fits within the broader landscape of human dietary patterns.
In the following sections, we will first define the main dietary patterns under consideration, then move through a comparative analysis of their nutrient profiles, health correlates, microbiome signatures, and economic dimensions. By the end, we hope to replace simple dichotomies – “vegetarian versus omnivore” – with a more realistic and useful picture: a continuum of food choices where both the inclusion of animal foods and the quality of plant foods shape outcomes in complex ways.
1. The continuum of plant-based diets: from flexibility to strictness
When discussing plant-based eating, it is essential to recognise that “vegetarian” is not a single category but rather a point on a spectrum. At one end lie diets that include significant amounts of animal foods; at the other, diets that exclude them entirely. Between these poles, there are several intermediate patterns, each with its own definition, prevalence, and nutritional implications (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025; Rolands et al., 2025).
Understanding this continuum helps avoid oversimplifications. Comparing a strict vegan to a conventional omnivore tells only part of the story. Many people today follow less restrictive plant‑based patterns, and their health and nutritional profiles may differ markedly from those of both vegans and heavy meat eaters. Moreover, the reasons for choosing a particular diet – health, ethics, environment, or religion – often correlate with other lifestyle behaviours that can independently influence health outcomes (Sandri et al., 2024).
1.1. Defining the dietary patterns
Spectrum of plant-based diets.
Flexitarianism involves eating meat sparingly and in small quantities, as in the Mediterranean diet. Pescetarianism includes only fish and seafood. Ovo-lacto vegetarianism also allows eggs and dairy products. Strict vegetarianism excludes all animal products (meat, fish, eggs). Veganism excludes all animal products (meat, poultry, fish, dairy, eggs), honey, and other animal products. Grammatikopoulou et al. (2025), figure 1. CC BY 4.0
To make meaningful comparisons, we first need clear definitions of the main dietary patterns considered in the scientific literature. Based on the World Health Organization framework and common usage in recent large cohort studies, five patterns are most frequently distinguished (Rolands et al., 2025; Siapco & Sabaté, 2018).
Omnivore (Western diet). This pattern includes both plant and animal foods without systematic restriction. In the context of comparative studies, however, “omnivore” often refers to a conventional Western diet characterised by daily or frequent consumption of red and processed meat, poultry, fish, eggs, dairy products, refined grains, and sugar‑sweetened foods and beverages (Bruns et al., 2024). In studies such as the Adventist Health Study‑2 (AHS‑2) and the EPIC‑Oxford cohort, the reference omnivore group typically consumes meat more than once per week and often daily (Orlich & Fraser, 2014; Siapco & Sabaté, 2018).
Flexitarian (semi‑vegetarian). This is a predominantly plant‑based diet that occasionally includes small amounts of meat, poultry, or fish. There is no single universal definition, but many studies define flexitarians as individuals who eat meat less than once per week or consume no more than 50 g of meat per day (Bruns et al., 2024; Rolands et al., 2025). The flexitarian pattern has grown in popularity, particularly in high‑income countries, as it offers a pragmatic middle ground for those wishing to reduce animal food consumption without eliminating it entirely (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
Pescetarian (pesco‑vegetarian). This diet excludes meat and poultry but includes fish and seafood. Dairy products and eggs may or may not be consumed; in most studies, pescetarians are allowed to eat dairy and eggs unless specified otherwise (Rolands et al., 2025; Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). The pescetarian pattern is often studied as a separate category because fish consumption provides long‑chain omega‑3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), which are largely absent from strict vegetarian and vegan diets (Klein et al., 2025).
Vegetarian (lacto‑ovo‑vegetarian). This pattern excludes all meat, poultry, and fish but includes eggs and dairy products. It is the most common form of vegetarianism in Western countries (Sandri et al., 2024). In large cohorts such as AHS‑2, lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians make up about 29% of the study population (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). From a nutritional standpoint, this diet can provide high‑quality protein, calcium, and vitamin B12 from dairy and eggs, though intakes of long‑chain omega‑3s and bioavailable iron may still be lower than in omnivore diets (Rolands et al., 2025).
Vegan. This is the most restrictive plant‑based pattern, excluding all foods of animal origin – meat, poultry, fish, eggs, dairy, and often honey and other animal‑derived ingredients. Vegans rely entirely on plant foods: grains, legumes, vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds, and plant‑based alternatives (e.g., soymilk, tofu, meat analogues). In the AHS‑2 cohort, vegans constitute about 8% of participants (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). While vegan diets can be nutritionally adequate when carefully planned, they require attention to vitamin B12, vitamin D, calcium, iron, zinc, and long‑chain omega‑3 fatty acids, often through fortified foods or supplements (Rolands et al., 2025; Leite et al., 2020).
These five patterns form a logical continuum: as one moves from omnivore towards vegan, the proportion of plant foods increases, the variety of plant protein sources often broadens, and the intake of animal‑derived nutrients gradually declines. However, as we will see later, simply moving along this continuum does not guarantee better health outcomes – the *quality* of plant foods chosen matters at least as much as the quantity of animal foods excluded (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
1.2. Prevalence and motives for dietary choice
Distribution of types of diets adopted (n = 22 181).
Sandri et al. (2024), figure 1. CC BY 4.0
How many people actually follow plant‑based diets? The answer varies greatly by country, culture, and how “vegetarian” or “vegan” is defined. In high‑income Western nations, vegetarians and vegans remain a minority, but their numbers have been growing steadily over the past decade. In the United States, estimates suggest that about 3–5% of adults identify as vegetarian, and approximately 1–2% as vegan (Sandri et al., 2024). In the United Kingdom, the proportion of vegetarians is similar, while veganism has seen a particularly sharp rise – the British vegan population reportedly quadrupled between 2014 and 2018, reaching about 1% of adults (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
However, these figures depend heavily on whether one uses self‑identification or strict dietary criteria. Large cohort studies that assess actual food intake, rather than asking for a label, often find slightly different proportions. In the Adventist Health Study‑2 (AHS‑2) – a North American cohort with a high proportion of plant‑based eaters due to religious affiliation – the distribution was as follows: 48% non‑vegetarian, 10% semi‑vegetarian, 6% pescetarian, 28% lacto‑ovo‑vegetarian, and 8% vegan (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). In the EPIC‑Oxford cohort (United Kingdom), the breakdown was 52% meat‑eaters, 15% fish‑eaters, 29% vegetarians, and 4% vegans (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). These figures illustrate that even within studies, the proportion of strict vegetarians and vegans is relatively small, which can limit statistical power when analysing health outcomes in these subgroups.
Globally, the highest prevalence of vegetarianism is found in India, where a large part of the population follows plant‑based diets for religious and cultural reasons (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025). In many low‑ and middle‑income countries, however, vegetarianism is often a matter of economic necessity rather than choice – a phenomenon sometimes termed “vegetarian by necessity” (Leite et al., 2020). In such settings, people may eat primarily plant‑based because animal foods are expensive or unavailable, and they often switch to omnivorous diets as soon as their income rises.
Motives for choosing a plant‑based diet
Why do people adopt vegetarian or vegan diets in high‑income countries, where a wide variety of foods is available? Research consistently points to a combination of factors, with health concerns, ethical considerations regarding animal welfare, and environmental awareness being the most frequently cited (Sandri et al., 2024; Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
Health is often the primary motive, particularly among those who adopt plant‑based diets in adulthood. Many people believe – and scientific evidence partly supports – that reducing or eliminating meat can lower the risk of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and certain cancers (Rosenfeld et al., 2023). However, as we will discuss later, the relationship is complex and depends heavily on the overall quality of the diet.
Animal welfare is another powerful driver, especially for vegans and long‑term vegetarians. Concerns about factory farming, animal suffering, and the ethics of killing animals for food lead many to exclude meat, fish, and sometimes all animal products (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
Environmental concerns have gained prominence in recent years. The impact of animal agriculture on greenhouse gas emissions, land use, water consumption, and biodiversity loss is substantial. For environmentally conscious individuals, reducing or eliminating animal foods is seen as a tangible way to lower their personal ecological footprint (Leite et al., 2020).
Religious and cultural traditions also play a role. Seventh‑day Adventists, for example, are encouraged to follow a plant‑based diet as part of their faith, which is why the AHS‑2 cohort has an unusually high proportion of vegetarians and vegans (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and other Eastern traditions also promote vegetarianism to varying degrees.
Interestingly, demographic patterns show that women are more likely than men to adopt plant‑based diets, and younger adults are more likely than older ones (Sandri et al., 2024). In many studies, vegetarians and vegans also tend to have higher levels of education and, in some cases, lower body mass index (BMI). However, a Spanish cross‑sectional study found that sociodemographic factors such as gender, age, education, income, and place of residence did not significantly predict dietary pattern choice – suggesting that health information has become widely democratised through the internet and social media (Sandri et al., 2024). In other words, plant‑based eating is no longer confined to any particular social or demographic niche.
It is also important to note that vegetarians and vegans often lead healthier lifestyles beyond diet. They tend to smoke less, drink less alcohol, engage in more physical activity, and sleep longer than omnivores (Sandri et al., 2024; Bruns et al., 2024). This “healthy volunteer effect” – also observed in the Adventist Health Study – means that some of the health benefits attributed to vegetarian diets may be partly due to these accompanying lifestyle factors rather than to diet alone (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025). Disentangling these effects is a major challenge in nutritional epidemiology and one that we will return to in later sections.
2. Nutrient profile: a comparative analysis of macro‑ and micronutrients
A diet is more than just a label. Whether a person calls themselves omnivore, flexitarian, vegetarian, or vegan tells us little about the actual nutritional quality of what they eat. Two individuals following the same dietary pattern can have vastly different intakes of protein, fat, vitamins, and minerals – depending on food choices within that pattern. Nevertheless, when large groups are compared, consistent differences in nutrient profiles emerge. These differences are not merely academic; they have direct implications for energy metabolism, tissue function, and long‑term health (Rolands et al., 2025; Klein et al., 2025).
In this section, we compare the five dietary patterns defined earlier – omnivore (Western), flexitarian, pescetarian, vegetarian (lacto‑ovo), and vegan – across key macronutrients and micronutrients. We begin with protein, the macronutrient that has historically attracted the most concern and debate regarding plant‑based diets.
2.1. Protein: quantity and sources
Daily requirements of essential amino acids for the average adult (mg/day) compared with total and true ileal amino acid availability (mg/day) for basal (A) and all-plant (B) lowest-cost diets in the United States.
Chungchunlam & Moughan (2024), figure 1. CC BY 4.0
Total protein intake
One of the most persistent myths about plant‑based diets is that they are inherently low in protein. The evidence does not support this claim, at least for adults in high‑income countries. A systematic review of observational studies found that total protein intake, expressed as a percentage of total energy, is remarkably similar across dietary patterns – though with some gradient (Rolands et al., 2025).
- Omnivores (Western diet): 15–17% of energy from protein
- Flexitarians: 14–16% of energy from protein
- Pescetarians: 14–17% of energy from protein
- Vegetarians (lacto‑ovo): 13–16% of energy from protein
- Vegans: 12–14% of energy from protein
In absolute terms, most adults in these studies consume well above the recommended dietary allowance (RDA) of 0.8 g protein per kilogram of body weight per day. For example, a typical vegan in the EPIC‑Oxford cohort obtained about 12–13% of energy from protein, which is more than sufficient for a sedentary adult (Rolands et al., 2025). The slightly lower percentage in vegans and vegetarians reflects the fact that plant‑based diets are often higher in carbohydrates (especially fibre) and sometimes lower in total energy, not a deficiency of protein per se.
However, some studies have noted that a minority of vegans – particularly those with very low energy intakes or who rely heavily on fruit and low‑protein vegetables – may fall below the recommended protein intake (Rolands et al., 2025). This is not an inherent flaw of veganism but rather a consequence of poor dietary planning, which can occur in any diet.
Plant versus animal protein proportion
What truly distinguishes the dietary patterns is not the total amount of protein, but its source. The proportion of protein coming from plants increases steadily along the continuum from omnivore to vegan (Rolands et al., 2025):
- Omnivores (Western diet): 30–40% of total protein from plants (the rest from meat, fish, eggs, dairy)
- Flexitarians: 40–60% from plants (varies widely by definition)
- Pescetarians: 50–70% from plants (fish provides animal protein)
- Vegetarians (lacto‑ovo): 70–85% from plants (eggs and dairy contribute animal protein)
- Vegans: 90–100% from plants (small amounts of animal protein may appear from contamination or hidden ingredients)
These figures come from several large studies, including the NutriNet‑Santé cohort (France) and the EPIC‑Oxford cohort (Rolands et al., 2025). The high plant protein proportion in vegan diets is expected, but it is noteworthy that even self‑identified vegetarians often consume some animal protein (from dairy and eggs), and that some self‑identified vegans may inadvertently consume small amounts of animal‑derived ingredients – reflecting the difficulty of maintaining a completely animal‑free diet in real‑world settings.
Main sources of plant protein
Where do people on different diets get their plant protein? A systematic review by Rolands and colleagues (2025) compiled data from 13 observational studies and found striking differences in the *variety* of plant protein sources consumed.
- Omnivores and flexitarians obtain most of their plant protein from grains (wheat, rice, corn, oats) – typically 60–80% of total plant protein intake. Other sources – nuts, seeds, legumes, and soy products – contribute much smaller fractions. This narrow reliance on grains means that the overall amino acid profile of their plant protein intake is often suboptimal, particularly in lysine, which is limited in many cereals (Rolands et al., 2025).
- Vegetarians (lacto‑ovo) also derive the largest share of plant protein from grains (around 50–75%), but they consume significantly more nuts and seeds, legumes (beans, lentils, chickpeas), and soy products than omnivores. For example, in the AHS‑2 cohort, vegetarians obtained about 16% of their plant protein from legumes and 9% from soy products (Rolands et al., 2025).
- Vegans have the most diverse plant protein portfolio. While grains still contribute a substantial share (about 60%), vegans also obtain roughly 20% of their plant protein from legumes and another 15–20% from soy products (tofu, tempeh, soymilk, meat analogues). Nuts and seeds contribute about 5–10% (Rolands et al., 2025). This diversity is nutritionally advantageous because different plant foods have complementary amino acid profiles: grains are low in lysine but rich in methionine and cysteine; legumes are low in methionine and cysteine but rich in lysine. By combining grains with legumes and soy, vegans can achieve a complete amino acid profile without animal products.
Protein quality: the digestibility dimension
Protein quantity tells only half the story. The body cannot use dietary protein unless it is digested and its constituent amino acids are absorbed. Protein quality is determined by two factors: the amino acid composition (does it provide all essential amino acids in adequate proportions?) and the digestibility (how much of the protein is actually absorbed?).
Animal proteins (meat, fish, eggs, dairy) are generally considered high‑quality because they contain all essential amino acids in proportions similar to human requirements and are highly digestible (true ileal digestibility >90%). Most plant proteins, in contrast, are somewhat less digestible (70–90%) due to the presence of cell walls, fibre, and antinutritional factors such as phytates, tannins, and protease inhibitors (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
The practical significance of these differences was illustrated by Chungchunlam and Moughan (2024) using linear programming models of least‑cost nutritionally adequate diets in the United States. When they corrected for true ileal amino acid digestibility (i.e., the amount of amino acids actually absorbed at the end of the small intestine), both omnivore and plant‑only diets met requirements – but the plant‑only diet was much closer to the margin. For example, digestible sulfur amino acids (methionine + cysteine) in the plant‑only diet were only 106% of the requirement, compared to 122% in the omnivore diet. Using the currently recommended protein quality metric – the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS) – the plant‑only diet scored 76% (for the FAO adult reference pattern) and only 62% (for the more stringent young child pattern), indicating that it would be considered a lower‑quality protein source for regulatory purposes (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
Does this matter for healthy adults consuming a varied diet? For most people, no – as long as total protein intake is sufficient and a variety of plant proteins is consumed. The body can compensate for moderate differences in digestibility by increasing protein turnover and by the complementary action of different plant foods. However, for populations with high protein requirements (e.g., growing children, pregnant and lactating women, the elderly, athletes) or those with low energy intakes, the lower digestibility of plant proteins could become clinically relevant (Rolands et al., 2025). This is one reason why national dietary guidelines in many countries recommend that vegetarians, and especially vegans, pay attention to protein variety and, in some cases, consider supplementation or fortified foods.
In summary, the evidence shows that protein intake is adequate across all dietary patterns in high‑income populations, but the source and quality differ substantially. Vegans consume the highest proportion of plant protein and the greatest variety of plant protein sources, which allows them to achieve a balanced amino acid profile. However, the lower digestibility of plant proteins means that vegans (and to a lesser extent vegetarians) may need slightly higher total protein intakes or more careful food combinations to achieve the same utilizable protein as omnivores. These nuances are often lost in oversimplified debates about whether plant‑based diets are “good” or “bad” for protein nutrition – the answer, as so often in nutrition science, is that it depends on how the diet is planned and executed.
2.2. Fats: from saturated to unsaturated
Comparison of plasma concentrations of individual n-3 fatty acids in individuals with different dietary habits.
(A) Plasma lipid concentrations of α-linolenic acid (ALA), (B) eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA), (C) docosapentaenoic acid (DPA), and (D) docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) are presented as percentages of total fatty acid methyl ester area (%FAME). A total of 62 individuals consuming a whole food diet (Western diet; WD), 69 consuming a flexitarian diet (Flex), 64 consuming a vegetarian diet (VG), and 57 consuming a vegan diet (VN) were analyzed. Results are presented as violin plots with the median (denoted by squares) and the 25th and 75th quartiles (denoted by dashed lines). Diet groups that do not have common indicators (a, b, c) are significantly different (Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Benjamini-Hochberg correction (p < 0,05)). Klein et al. (2025), figure 3. CC BY 4.0
Fatty acids are fundamental to human health. They serve as concentrated energy stores, form the structural backbone of cell membranes, and act as signalling molecules that regulate inflammation, blood clotting, and blood pressure (Klein et al., 2025). Unlike protein, where total intake is often adequate across diets, fat composition – the types of fatty acids consumed – varies dramatically between dietary patterns. These differences are among the most consistent and biologically significant findings in comparative nutrition research.
Saturated fatty acids (SFA)
Saturated fats have long been associated with increased low‑density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol and, through that mechanism, with higher cardiovascular disease risk. The primary dietary sources of SFA are animal‑based foods: red meat, processed meat, full‑fat dairy products (butter, cheese, cream), and some tropical plant oils (coconut oil, palm oil).
Not surprisingly, individuals following plant‑based diets consume substantially less SFA than omnivores. The NuEva study, a German cross‑sectional investigation of 252 healthy adults, measured plasma and erythrocyte fatty acid profiles across four dietary groups: omnivores (Western diet), flexitarians, vegetarians, and vegans (Klein et al., 2025). The results were striking:
- Plasma SFA (reflecting recent dietary intake) was lowest in vegans, intermediate in vegetarians and flexitarians, and highest in omnivores. Vegans had significantly lower levels of palmitic acid (C16:0) – the most abundant SFA in the diet – compared to all other groups.
- Odd‑chain saturated fatty acids (pentadecanoic acid, C15:0; heptadecanoic acid, C17:0) are considered biomarkers of dairy and ruminant fat intake. Vegans had the lowest levels of these fatty acids, confirming their adherence to a dairy‑free diet. However, detectable levels persisted in vegans, possibly due to endogenous synthesis from propionate produced by gut bacterial fermentation of dietary fibre (Klein et al., 2025).
Interestingly, while plasma SFA differed markedly between groups, erythrocyte (red blood cell) SFA did not. This suggests that cell membranes regulate their SFA composition independently of short‑term dietary fluctuations, likely through endogenous synthesis. Erythrocyte SFA may therefore reflect long‑term metabolic regulation rather than recent dietary intake (Klein et al., 2025).
Monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFA)
Monounsaturated fats, particularly oleic acid (C18:1n‑9), are abundant in olive oil, rapeseed (canola) oil, avocados, and nuts. Unlike SFA, MUFA are not strongly correlated with dietary intake because the body can synthesise them endogenously from saturated fats via the enzyme stearoyl‑CoA desaturase (Klein et al., 2025).
In the NuEva study, total plasma MUFA did not differ significantly between dietary groups. However, vegans showed a trend toward higher oleic acid levels in erythrocyte membranes compared to flexitarians and vegetarians, possibly reflecting a higher intake of oleic‑rich plant oils (olive oil, rapeseed oil) in vegan diets (Klein et al., 2025).
Polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA): the omega‑6 and omega‑3 families
Polyunsaturated fats are where plant‑based and omnivorous diets diverge most sharply. PUFA are classified into two families: omega‑6 (n‑6) and omega‑3 (n‑3). Both are essential – the body cannot synthesise them and must obtain them from food. However, they compete for the same enzymes (desaturases and elongases) involved in the synthesis of long‑chain metabolites, and their balance has important implications for inflammation and cardiovascular health.
Omega‑6 fatty acids: linoleic acid (LA) and arachidonic acid (ARA)
Linoleic acid (LA, C18:2n‑6) is the primary dietary omega‑6. It is abundant in vegetable oils (sunflower, corn, soybean), nuts, seeds, and many processed foods. Arachidonic acid (ARA, C20:4n‑6) is a long‑chain metabolite of LA found almost exclusively in animal foods – meat, eggs, and especially organ meats.
The NuEva study found that vegans and vegetarians had significantly higher plasma and erythrocyte levels of LA than omnivores, reflecting their higher intake of vegetable oils and plant‑based foods (Klein et al., 2025). Conversely, omnivores had higher levels of ARA, which is derived directly from animal foods. Flexitarians occupied an intermediate position.
This pattern has functional consequences. ARA is the precursor of pro‑inflammatory eicosanoids (prostaglandins, leukotrienes, thromboxanes). High ARA levels relative to EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid, an omega‑3) are generally considered pro‑inflammatory. The ARA/EPA ratio was highest in vegans, intermediate in vegetarians and flexitarians, and lowest in omnivores – a finding that initially seems to favour omnivores (Klein et al., 2025). However, as we will see below, the interpretation is more complex because absolute levels of EPA and DHA also differ.
Omega‑3 fatty acids: ALA, EPA, and DHA
Alpha‑linolenic acid (ALA, C18:3n‑3) is the plant‑based omega‑3, found in flaxseeds, chia seeds, walnuts, hemp seeds, and their oils. The long‑chain derivatives – eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA, C20:5n‑3) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA, C22:6n‑3) – are found almost exclusively in fatty fish (salmon, mackerel, sardines), seafood, and, to a lesser extent, in eggs and dairy from grass‑fed animals.
The conversion of ALA to EPA and DHA in humans is limited. Estimates suggest that less than 5–10% of ALA is converted to EPA, and less than 1–5% to DHA (Klein et al., 2025). This conversion is further reduced by high dietary LA intake, because LA and ALA compete for the same desaturase enzymes (delta‑6‑desaturase and delta‑5‑desaturase). Since plant‑based diets are typically high in LA, the already inefficient conversion becomes even less effective.
The NuEva study documented a clear gradient in omega‑3 status across dietary patterns (Klein et al., 2025):
- ALA levels in plasma were somewhat higher in vegans and omnivores than in vegetarians and flexitarians, but the differences were not always statistically significant. In erythrocytes, vegans had slightly higher ALA than omnivores – possibly reflecting higher regular ALA intake or adaptive incorporation into membranes.
- EPA and DHA showed a stepwise decline: omnivores > flexitarians > vegetarians > vegans. Vegans had the lowest levels of both EPA and DHA in plasma and erythrocytes.
- The omega‑3 index – a validated biomarker of cardiovascular risk defined as the sum of EPA and DHA in erythrocyte membranes – followed the same pattern. Vegans had the lowest omega‑3 index, vegetators intermediate, and omnivores the highest (Klein et al., 2025).
These differences are not trivial. Low EPA and DHA status has been associated with increased risk of cardiovascular disease, cognitive decline, and mood disorders in observational studies. However, the clinical significance for healthy young vegans is unclear, as most inflammatory markers in the NuEva study did not differ between groups – a point we will return to in Section 4.
Trans fatty acids (TFA) and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA)
Trans fatty acids occur naturally in ruminant animal products (dairy, beef, lamb) and are also produced industrially by partial hydrogenation of vegetable oils (though industrial TFA have been largely phased out in many countries). Conjugated linoleic acid (CLA) is a group of isomers found almost exclusively in dairy and ruminant meat.
In the NuEva study, vegans had significantly lower levels of both TFA and CLA in plasma and erythrocytes compared to omnivores, flexitarians, and vegetarians (Klein et al., 2025). This confirms that vegans effectively avoid dairy and ruminant fats – but also suggests that they may consume fewer ultra‑processed plant‑based alternatives, which can contain industrially produced TFA (Klein et al., 2025). The lower CLA levels in vegans (less than half of omnivore levels) provide a sensitive biomarker of long‑term dairy avoidance.
Ratios and their interpretation
Beyond individual fatty acids, the balance between omega‑6 and omega‑3 is often discussed as a risk factor for chronic disease. The n‑6/n‑3 ratio was significantly higher in flexitarians, vegetarians, and vegans compared to omnivores, with vegans having the highest ratio (Klein et al., 2025). This reflects the combination of high LA intake (plant oils) and low EPA/DHA intake (no fish) in plant‑based diets.
Is a high n‑6/n‑3 ratio necessarily harmful? The evidence is mixed. Some experts argue that the ratio matters less than the absolute intake of EPA and DHA. Others maintain that high LA intake can suppress ALA conversion and promote a pro‑inflammatory eicosanoid profile. What is clear is that vegetarians and vegans have a fundamentally different fatty acid profile than omnivores – and that this profile is not inherently “better” or “worse”, but rather comes with its own set of trade‑offs. Lower SFA and higher LA are generally favourable for cardiovascular risk, but lower EPA and DHA may offset some of these benefits (Klein et al., 2025; Bruns et al., 2024).
Summary
The fat composition of plant‑based diets differs from omnivorous diets in several consistent ways:
- Lower saturated fat (especially from red meat and dairy) – a cardioprotective feature.
- Higher linoleic acid (omega‑6) – a double‑edged sword: beneficial for LDL cholesterol but potentially unfavourable for omega‑3 conversion.
- Lower long‑chain omega‑3 (EPA, DHA) – a potential vulnerability, especially for vegans, who rely entirely on endogenous conversion from ALA.
- Lower trans fats and CLA – reflecting avoidance of ruminant animal products and, possibly, lower intake of ultra‑processed foods.
These differences are not merely academic. They translate into distinct patterns of circulating fatty acids, which in turn influence cell membrane composition, eicosanoid production, and, over the long term, cardiovascular risk. However, as we will see in Section 4, the relationship between dietary fat composition and actual inflammatory markers in healthy individuals is not straightforward – and other components of plant‑based diets (fibre, antioxidants, phytochemicals) may modify or compensate for the lower omega‑3 status.
2.3. Key micronutrients: where are the risks and where are the benefits?
Macronutrients – protein and fat – receive much attention in discussions of plant‑based diets, but micronutrients are equally, if not more, critical. Unlike energy and protein, which the body can to some extent regulate, many vitamins and minerals must be obtained in adequate amounts from the diet on a regular basis. Deficiencies can develop slowly, often without obvious symptoms, but over time they can impair immune function, bone health, cognitive performance, and cardiovascular health.
The micronutrient profiles of plant‑based diets are neither uniformly better nor uniformly worse than those of omnivorous diets. Instead, they show a characteristic pattern: some nutrients are consistently higher in vegetarians and vegans, while others are lower or less bioavailable. Understanding this pattern is essential for evaluating the overall nutritional adequacy of different dietary patterns (Leite et al., 2020; Siapco & Sabaté, 2018).
Nutrients that are generally higher in plant‑based diets
Dietary fibre. Although not a micronutrient, fibre is a key component of plant foods with profound health implications. Vegans and vegetarians consume significantly more fibre than omnivores – in the AHS‑2 cohort, mean fibre intake was 46.7 g/day for vegans, 37.5 g/day for lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians, and 30.4 g/day for non‑vegetarians (standardised to 2000 kcal) (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). High fibre intake is associated with lower risks of cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, colorectal cancer, and all‑cause mortality.
Folate (vitamin B9). Plant foods – especially dark green leafy vegetables, legumes, and fortified grains – are rich sources of folate. Vegans and vegetarians typically have higher folate intakes and serum folate levels than omnivores (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Adequate folate status is particularly important for preventing neural tube defects during pregnancy and for lowering homocysteine levels, a risk factor for cardiovascular disease.
Vitamin C. Fruits and vegetables are the primary dietary sources of vitamin C. Unsurprisingly, vegetarians and vegans consume substantially more vitamin C than omnivores. In the AHS‑2 cohort, mean vitamin C intake was 293 mg/day for vegans, 271 mg/day for vegetarians, and 250 mg/day for non‑vegetarians (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Vitamin C acts as a potent antioxidant, supports immune function, and enhances the absorption of non‑haem iron from plant foods – a critical interaction for plant‑based diets.
Vitamin E. Nuts, seeds, and vegetable oils are rich in vitamin E (tocopherols). Vegans and vegetarians in the AHS‑2 had higher vitamin E intakes than non‑vegetarians (18.5 vs. 20.0 vs. 20.1 mg/day, respectively) (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Vitamin E protects cell membranes from oxidative damage.
Magnesium and potassium. Both minerals are abundant in plant foods – whole grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, and vegetables. Vegetarians and vegans consistently have higher intakes of magnesium and potassium than omnivores (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Adequate magnesium is important for muscle and nerve function, blood glucose control, and blood pressure regulation; potassium helps counteract the hypertensive effects of sodium.
Nutrients that are lower or less bioavailable in plant‑based diets
Vitamin B12 (cobalamin). This is the most critical nutrient of concern for plant‑based diets, especially for vegans. Vitamin B12 is not produced by plants or animals – it is synthesised by certain bacteria and archaea. In the food supply, the only reliable natural sources are animal products: meat, fish, eggs, and dairy. Plants do not contain active B12, and although some fermented plant foods (tempeh, sauerkraut) or algae (nori, spirulina) have been claimed to contain B12, the forms present are often inactive analogues that can actually interfere with B12 metabolism (Leite et al., 2020).
Consequently, vegans have very low dietary B12 intake unless they consume fortified foods (plant milks, breakfast cereals, nutritional yeast) or take supplements. In the EPIC‑Oxford cohort, vegans had a median B12 intake of only 0.78 μg/day – far below the recommended 2.4 μg/day (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). In contrast, vegetarians who consume dairy and eggs had intakes around 3 μg/day, and omnivores around 7–8 μg/day (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Vitamin B12 deficiency can lead to megaloblastic anaemia, neuropathy, cognitive impairment, and elevated homocysteine (a risk factor for cardiovascular disease). The German Nutrition Society and the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics both emphasise that vegans must obtain B12 from fortified foods or supplements (Leite et al., 2020).
Iron. Vegetarians and vegans often consume as much or even more total iron than omnivores, because plant foods like legumes, whole grains, and dark leafy greens are rich in iron. In the AHS‑2, mean iron intake was 22.2 mg/day for vegans, 22.1 mg/day for vegetarians, and 20.0 mg/day for non‑vegetarians (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). However, the bioavailability of iron from plant foods is much lower than from animal foods.
Dietary iron exists in two forms: haem iron (from animal tissues) and non‑haem iron (from plants). Haem iron is absorbed at 15–35% efficiency, while non‑haem iron absorption is typically 2–20% and is strongly influenced by other dietary components. Phytates (in whole grains, legumes, nuts), polyphenols (in tea, coffee, wine), and calcium can inhibit non‑haem iron absorption, while vitamin C enhances it. As a result, vegetarians and vegans have lower iron stores (ferritin levels) than omnivores, despite similar or higher iron intakes. Iron deficiency is more common among vegetarian women of reproductive age, though clinical anaemia may not be more prevalent if overall intake is adequate (Leite et al., 2020).
Zinc. Like iron, zinc is less bioavailable from plant foods due to phytate binding. Vegetarians and vegans often have lower zinc intakes than omnivores – in the AHS‑2, mean zinc intake was 11.3 mg/day for vegans, 11.5 mg/day for vegetarians, and 11.9 mg/day for non‑vegetarians (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). However, zinc requirements may be higher for plant‑based diets because of lower absorption. Overt zinc deficiency is rare in high‑income countries, but suboptimal status has been reported in some vegetarian populations. Food preparation techniques such as soaking, sprouting, and fermenting legumes and grains can reduce phytate content and improve zinc bioavailability (Leite et al., 2020).
Calcium. Dairy products are the major source of calcium in Western omnivorous diets. Vegans who avoid dairy must obtain calcium from plant sources: fortified plant milks, calcium‑set tofu, leafy greens (kale, bok choy, broccoli), tahini, and almonds. However, some plant foods high in oxalates (spinach, Swiss chard, beet greens) have very low calcium bioavailability because calcium oxalate is insoluble. In the AHS‑2, mean calcium intake was 833 mg/day for vegans, 1145 mg/day for vegetarians, and 1072 mg/day for non‑vegetarians – suggesting that many vegans may fall below the recommended 1000–1200 mg/day (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Low calcium intake over the long term, combined with potentially lower vitamin D status, may increase the risk of osteoporosis and fractures, particularly in vegan populations (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
Vitamin D. Vitamin D is unique because the body can synthesise it when skin is exposed to sunlight. Dietary sources are limited: fatty fish, egg yolks, liver, and fortified foods (milk, plant milks, breakfast cereals). Vegans who do not consume fortified foods are at high risk of vitamin D insufficiency, especially at higher latitudes during winter. In the AHS‑2, vitamin D intake from food (excluding supplements) was 2.4 μg/day for vegans, 4.6 μg/day for vegetarians, and 6.1 μg/day for non‑vegetarians – well below the recommended 15 μg/day (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Vitamin D deficiency impairs calcium absorption and bone health and has been linked to immune dysfunction and increased infection risk.
Iodine. Iodine is essential for thyroid hormone synthesis. The iodine content of plant foods depends heavily on soil levels, which vary geographically. In many countries, iodised salt is the primary strategy for ensuring adequate iodine intake. Vegans who avoid iodised salt and do not consume seafood or dairy (both rich in iodine) may be at risk of deficiency. The Italian Society of Human Nutrition and other bodies recommend the use of iodised salt for vegetarians and vegans (Leite et al., 2020).
Selenium. Selenium intakes vary greatly by region due to soil selenium levels. In Europe, many soils are selenium‑poor, and animal products (meat, fish, eggs, dairy) are important dietary sources because animals accumulate selenium from feed. Vegans can obtain selenium from Brazil nuts (just one or two nuts per day provides the recommended intake), but otherwise may have low intakes. The German Nutrition Society advises vegans to include Brazil nuts or selenium‑fortified foods in their diet (Leite et al., 2020).
Putting it together: a pattern, not a judgement
The micronutrient profile of plant‑based diets is not inherently “good” or “bad”. Rather, it reflects the logical consequence of excluding or limiting animal foods. Vegetarians and vegans excel in fibre, folate, vitamin C, vitamin E, magnesium, and potassium – nutrients that are abundant in vegetables, fruits, whole grains, nuts, and seeds. However, they face higher risks of inadequacy for vitamin B12, iron (bioavailability), zinc, calcium, vitamin D, iodine, and selenium – nutrients that are either concentrated in animal foods or less bioavailable from plants.
The practical implication is clear: a well‑planned plant‑based diet can be nutritionally adequate, but it requires attention to the “critical” nutrients. For vegetarians who include dairy and eggs, the risks are moderate. For vegans, they are substantial unless fortified foods or supplements are used. As the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics stated in its position paper, “well‑planned vegetarian diets are appropriate for all stages of the life cycle” – but the emphasis on *well‑planned* is crucial (Leite et al., 2020). Unplanned or poorly executed plant‑based diets can indeed lead to deficiencies, just as poorly planned omnivorous diets can lead to excesses of saturated fat, sodium, and calories.
In the next section, we will move from nutrients to health outcomes – examining how these differences in macro‑ and micronutrient profiles translate into actual differences in cardiometabolic markers, disease risk, and mortality.
3. Cardiometabolic markers and mortality: an objective view
The ultimate question for many readers is straightforward: do plant‑based diets lead to better health outcomes, and if so, by how much? This section examines the evidence on cardiovascular risk factors – blood lipids, blood pressure, markers of glucose metabolism – as well as longer‑term outcomes such as metabolic syndrome, type 2 diabetes, and mortality. As we shall see, the answers are not as simple as “vegetarians live longer”, but clear patterns do emerge when large, well‑controlled studies are compared.
A note on interpretation: most of the evidence comes from observational cohort studies, which can show associations but cannot prove causation. Vegetarians and vegans tend to have healthier lifestyles overall – they smoke less, drink less alcohol, exercise more, and have lower body mass indices (Sandri et al., 2024; Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025). These factors, rather than diet alone, may explain part of any observed health advantage. Randomised controlled trials are fewer and shorter in duration, but they provide complementary evidence on intermediate markers such as cholesterol and blood pressure.
3.1. Lipid profile and blood pressure
Total and LDL cholesterol
The most consistent and robust finding in comparative nutrition research is that plant‑based diets lower total and LDL cholesterol. This effect is dose‑dependent: the more restrictive the diet (i.e., the less animal fat consumed), the greater the reduction.
In the Adventist Health Study‑2 (AHS‑2), a large North American cohort, mean total cholesterol levels (adjusted for age, sex, and race) were lowest in vegans, followed by lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians, pescetarians, semi‑vegetarians, and finally non‑vegetarians (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). Similarly, the EPIC‑Oxford cohort found that vegetarians and vegans had significantly lower total and LDL cholesterol than meat‑eaters (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018).
A meta‑analysis of randomised controlled trials by Wang and colleagues (2015) – cited in Leite et al. (2020) – quantified the effect: vegetarian diets reduced total cholesterol by a mean difference of –0.36 mmol/L (95% CI: –0.55 to –0.17) and LDL cholesterol by –0.34 mmol/L (95% CI: –0.57 to –0.11) compared to omnivorous control diets. Vegan diets tended to show even larger effects. Importantly, these changes were observed in trials lasting several weeks to months, suggesting that the lipid‑lowering effect occurs relatively quickly after adopting a plant‑based diet.
What explains this effect? Three mechanisms are likely. First, plant‑based diets are lower in saturated fat, particularly from red meat and full‑fat dairy. Second, they are higher in dietary fibre, which binds bile acids and increases cholesterol excretion. Third, plant foods contain plant sterols and stanols, which compete with cholesterol for absorption in the gut (Leite et al., 2020).
HDL cholesterol
High‑density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol is often called “good” cholesterol because it transports cholesterol from peripheral tissues back to the liver for excretion. The effect of plant‑based diets on HDL is less favourable. In the meta‑analysis by Wang et al. (2015), vegetarian diets were associated with a modest reduction in HDL cholesterol (mean difference –0.10 mmol/L, 95% CI: –0.14 to –0.06) (Leite et al., 2020).
Does this matter? The relationship between HDL and cardiovascular disease is complex. While low HDL is a risk factor in epidemiological studies, drug trials that raise HDL have not consistently shown benefit. Moreover, the quality and function of HDL particles may be more important than their absolute number. Some evidence suggests that plant‑based diets may improve HDL function even if total HDL concentration decreases slightly (Klein et al., 2025). Nonetheless, the reduction in HDL is a consistent observation and should be noted.
Triglycerides
Fasting triglycerides are another component of the lipid profile. The evidence on triglycerides and plant‑based diets is mixed. In some studies, vegetarians and vegans have lower triglycerides than omnivores; in others, no significant difference is found. The NuEva study reported that omnivores had significantly higher triglycerides than both flexitarians and vegans, but the difference lost statistical significance after adjustment for confounders (age, sex, BMI, physical activity) (Klein et al., 2025). A meta‑analysis by Wang et al. (2015) found no significant effect of vegetarian diets on triglycerides (mean difference +0.04 mmol/L, 95% CI: –0.05 to +0.13) (Leite et al., 2020).
The reason for this variability may be that triglyceride levels are strongly influenced by carbohydrate intake and quality. Some plant‑based diets that are high in refined carbohydrates (white bread, white rice, sugary snacks) could raise triglycerides, while those rich in whole grains and fibre tend to lower them. This highlights the importance of diet *quality*, a theme we will return to in Section 5.
Blood pressure
Hypertension is a major risk factor for stroke, heart attack, and kidney disease. A meta‑analysis of seven randomised controlled trials (Yokoyama et al., 2014, cited in Leite et al., 2020) found that vegetarian diets significantly reduced both systolic and diastolic blood pressure compared to omnivorous control diets. The mean differences were –4.8 mmHg for systolic blood pressure (95% CI: –6.6 to –3.1) and –2.2 mmHg for diastolic blood pressure (95% CI: –3.5 to –1.0).
The AHS‑2 provided further support. In white participants, the odds ratio for prevalent hypertension was 0.37 (95% CI: 0.19–0.74) for vegans and 0.57 (95% CI: 0.36–0.92) for lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians compared to non‑vegetarians (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). In black participants, the protective effect was also significant, though somewhat attenuated. When body mass index (BMI) was added to the statistical model, the effect sizes decreased – suggesting that part of the blood pressure benefit of plant‑based diets is mediated through lower body weight. However, a direct effect of diet (higher potassium, lower sodium, higher fibre) likely also contributes.
Why does this matter?
Taken together, the evidence on lipids and blood pressure consistently favours plant‑based diets, particularly those that are more restrictive (vegan > vegetarian > flexitarian > omnivore). The improvements in total cholesterol, LDL cholesterol, and blood pressure are of a magnitude that, at the population level, would be expected to translate into meaningful reductions in cardiovascular events. However, as we will see in the next subsection, the picture becomes more nuanced when we look at clinical endpoints such as metabolic syndrome, diabetes, and mortality – and when we account for the “healthy volunteer” effect.
3.2. Metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes
Beyond individual risk factors such as cholesterol and blood pressure, researchers often examine clusters of abnormalities that together confer a higher risk of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. The metabolic syndrome – defined as the presence of at least three of the following: abdominal obesity, high triglycerides, low HDL cholesterol, high blood pressure, and elevated fasting glucose – is one such cluster. Type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) itself is a major chronic disease with growing global prevalence, and its relationship with diet has been intensively studied.
Metabolic syndrome
Cross‑sectional analyses from large cohorts consistently show that vegetarians and vegans have a lower prevalence of metabolic syndrome than omnivores. In the AHS‑2 calibration sample (n = 773), the prevalence of metabolic syndrome was 25.2% among vegetarians (vegans plus lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians), 37.6% among semi‑vegetarians (pescetarians plus semi‑vegetarians), and 39.7% among non‑vegetarians (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). After adjusting for age, sex, ethnicity, physical activity, smoking, alcohol, and energy intake, vegetarians had 0.44 times the odds of having metabolic syndrome compared to non‑vegetarians (95% CI: 0.30–0.64). Notably, vegetarians had more favourable levels of every metabolic syndrome component except HDL cholesterol – and even for HDL, the difference was not statistically significant in the adjusted analysis (Orlich & Fraser, 2014).
The NuEva study in Germany, which used a continuous metabolic syndrome severity score (MetS‑score) rather than a simple yes/no classification, found that flexitarians had the most favourable (lowest) MetS‑scores, followed closely by vegans, with omnivores having the highest (least favourable) scores (Bruns et al., 2024). All groups had scores below zero, indicating low absolute risk, but the gradient was clear: reducing meat intake was associated with a better metabolic profile.
Type 2 diabetes
The association between plant‑based diets and type 2 diabetes risk is one of the most robust findings in nutritional epidemiology. A meta‑analysis of observational studies (cited in Leite et al., 2020) found that vegetarian diets were associated with a 36% lower risk of developing T2DM (odds ratio = 0.64, 95% CI: 0.57–0.74). Vegan diets showed an even stronger association (OR = 0.59, 95% CI: 0.39–0.91).
Data from the AHS‑2 illustrate this clearly. In a cross‑sectional analysis of 60,903 participants, the prevalence of self‑reported type 2 diabetes increased stepwise across dietary patterns: 2.9% in vegans, 3.2% in lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians, 4.8% in pescetarians, 6.1% in semi‑vegetarians, and 7.6% in non‑vegetarians (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). After adjusting for age, sex, race, education, income, physical activity, television watching, sleep, alcohol use, smoking, and body mass index (BMI), the odds ratios for prevalent diabetes compared to non‑vegetarians were 0.51 for vegans (95% CI: 0.40–0.66), 0.54 for lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians (95% CI: 0.49–0.60), 0.70 for pescetarians (95% CI: 0.61–0.80), and 0.76 for semi‑vegetarians (95% CI: 0.65–0.90). Notably, these adjustments included BMI, which is itself influenced by diet; thus, the protective effect remained even after accounting for differences in body weight.
Prospective analyses from AHS‑2 confirmed these cross‑sectional findings. Over a two‑year follow‑up period, incident diabetes was reported by 0.54% of vegans, 1.08% of lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians, 1.29% of pescetarians, 0.92% of semi‑vegetarians, and 2.12% of non‑vegetarians. In multivariate logistic regression (adjusting for the same covariates, including BMI), the odds ratios compared to non‑vegetarians were 0.38 for vegans (95% CI: 0.24–0.62), 0.62 for lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians (95% CI: 0.50–0.76), 0.79 for pescetarians (95% CI: 0.58–1.09), and 0.49 for semi‑vegetarians (95% CI: 0.31–0.76) (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). The protective effect was seen in both black and non‑black participants, though the point estimates were somewhat stronger in blacks.
Possible mechanisms
Several mechanisms likely explain the lower risk of T2DM in plant‑based eaters. First, vegetarians and vegans have lower body weight and less abdominal adiposity, which directly improves insulin sensitivity. Second, plant‑based diets are typically higher in dietary fibre, which slows carbohydrate absorption and reduces postprandial glucose excursions. Third, they are richer in magnesium, a mineral involved in insulin signalling. Fourth, plant foods contain a wide array of polyphenols and other bioactive compounds that may improve insulin sensitivity through anti‑inflammatory and antioxidant effects. Finally, the lower intake of saturated fat and higher intake of unsaturated fat may also contribute to better beta‑cell function (Leite et al., 2020; Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
A note of caution
Despite the consistency of these findings, some researchers urge caution. Grammatikopoulou and colleagues (2025) note that much of the evidence comes from the Adventist Health Studies, where participants are Seventh‑day Adventists – a religious group that, in addition to following plant‑based diets, also abstains from smoking and alcohol and places a strong emphasis on physical activity and community support. The “healthy volunteer effect” may be particularly pronounced in this population. Moreover, meta‑analyses of observational studies on vegetarianism and diabetes often rate the evidence as “low certainty” due to heterogeneity in definitions, residual confounding, and the possibility of reverse causation (people with existing health concerns may adopt plant‑based diets).
Nevertheless, the consistency across different populations – including the EPIC‑Oxford cohort in the UK, which is not restricted to Adventists – lends confidence to the conclusion that plant‑based dietary patterns are associated with a lower risk of type 2 diabetes, and that the association is at least partly independent of body weight.
In the next subsection, we will examine the most debated outcome: all‑cause and cause‑specific mortality. Here, as we shall see, the evidence is less clear‑cut, and the role of lifestyle confounders becomes even more critical.
3.3. All‑cause and cardiovascular mortality
If plant‑based diets improve blood lipids, blood pressure, and diabetes risk, one would logically expect them to also reduce mortality – particularly deaths from cardiovascular disease (CVD). The evidence on mortality, however, is less straightforward than on intermediate risk factors. Large cohort studies have produced somewhat conflicting results, and the interpretation is complicated by the “healthy volunteer” effect and differences in study populations.
Findings from the Adventist Health Study‑2 (AHS‑2)
The AHS‑2 has reported the most favourable mortality outcomes for vegetarians. In a mean follow‑up of 5.79 years (73,308 participants), all vegetarians combined (vegans, lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians, pescetarians, and semi‑vegetarians) had a 12% lower risk of all‑cause mortality compared to non‑vegetarians (hazard ratio [HR] = 0.88; 95% CI: 0.80–0.97) (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). When analysed by specific dietary pattern:
- Vegans: HR = 0.85 (95% CI: 0.73–1.01) – a 15% reduction that narrowly missed conventional statistical significance.
- Lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians: HR = 0.91 (95% CI: 0.82–1.00) – a 9% reduction, borderline significant.
- Pescetarians: HR = 0.81 (95% CI: 0.69–0.94) – a 19% reduction, statistically significant.
- Semi‑vegetarians: HR = 0.92 (95% CI: 0.75–1.13) – a non‑significant 8% reduction.
For cardiovascular mortality specifically, the pattern was similar but with wider confidence intervals. Pescetarians had a 35% lower risk of dying from ischaemic heart disease (HR = 0.65; 95% CI: 0.43–0.97), while the reductions for vegans (HR = 0.90) and lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians (HR = 0.82) were not statistically significant (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). Notably, the protective effects were stronger in men than in women, though the reasons for this sex difference are unclear.
Findings from EPIC‑Oxford and the Oxford Vegetarian Study
The British cohorts have produced more muted results. In a combined analysis of the EPIC‑Oxford and Oxford Vegetarian Study (65,429 participants, mean follow‑up approximately 10–17 years), there was no significant difference in all‑cause mortality between vegetarians and regular meat‑eaters (HR = 1.00; 95% CI: 0.93–1.08 for vegetarians compared to meat‑eaters) (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). Vegans actually had a non‑significant *higher* risk (HR = 1.14; 95% CI: 0.97–1.35), though this may reflect the small number of vegans in the cohort (only 4% of participants) and consequent low statistical power.
For ischaemic heart disease mortality, vegetarians and vegans showed a non‑significant 15% lower risk (HR = 0.85; 95% CI: 0.51–1.44 for vegans; HR = 1.00; 95% CI: 0.80–1.25 for vegetarians). For all cancers combined, no significant difference was observed between vegetarians and meat‑eaters (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018).
The contrast between the AHS‑2 and EPIC‑Oxford findings is striking. Why do two large, well‑conducted studies reach different conclusions? Several explanations have been proposed.
Possible reasons for discrepant mortality findings
1. The “healthy volunteer” effect. Adventists are a highly health‑conscious population. Even the non‑vegetarians in AHS‑2 may be healthier than the general population, but the *additional* benefit of vegetarianism might still be detectable because the baseline health behaviours are well controlled. In EPIC‑Oxford, the general population comparison may involve more confounding by lifestyle factors that are difficult to measure fully.
2. Duration of follow‑up. The AHS‑2 mortality analysis had a mean follow‑up of only 5.79 years, which is relatively short for detecting diet‑related differences in mortality, especially in a middle‑aged cohort. EPIC‑Oxford had longer follow‑up (up to 17 years). Longer follow‑up might reveal convergence of risks as the cohort ages, or it might dilute effects if participants change their diets over time.
3. Differences in dietary patterns and nutrient intake. British vegetarians may have different eating habits than American Adventist vegetarians. For example, the EPIC‑Oxford vegetarians consumed less fibre and more dairy and eggs than AHS‑2 vegetarians (Siapco & Sabaté, 2018). The quality of plant foods – not just the absence of meat – may differ between cohorts.
4. Statistical power for vegans. Both cohorts had relatively small numbers of vegans (4% in EPIC‑Oxford, 8% in AHS‑2), leading to wide confidence intervals and imprecise estimates. The apparent higher mortality risk for vegans in EPIC‑Oxford could easily be due to chance.
Meta‑analyses and the overall picture
Several meta‑analyses have attempted to synthesise the available cohort data. A meta‑analysis of eight prospective observational studies (cited in Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025) found that vegetarians had a similar risk of all‑cause mortality compared to non‑vegetarians, and similar cerebrovascular mortality. However, vegetarians did have a reduced risk of ischaemic heart disease mortality – though the evidence was rated as “very low certainty” due to heterogeneity and risk of bias (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
Another recent analysis – comparing the Planetary Health Diet Index (PHDI) and the Mediterranean Diet score (MEDAS) in a large Spanish cohort (ENRICA, n = 11,488) – found that higher adherence to either plant‑based pattern was associated with approximately 21–22% lower all‑cause mortality over a mean follow‑up of 14.4 years (Riera et al., 2025). This suggests that plant‑rich dietary patterns, whether strictly vegetarian or more flexibly Mediterranean, are associated with longevity benefits – but the magnitude of benefit may depend on the specific dietary context and the comparator diet.
The role of diet quality
An important nuance emerged from studies that distinguish between healthful and unhealthful plant‑based diets (Rosenfeld et al., 2023). A high score on the healthful Plant‑Based Diet Index (hPDI) – reflecting high intake of whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, and low intake of animal foods – is associated with significantly lower all‑cause mortality. In contrast, a high score on the unhealthful PDI (uPDI) – reflecting high intake of refined grains, fruit juices, potatoes, sweets, and sugar‑sweetened beverages – is associated with *higher* mortality, even though both indices are “plant‑based” in the sense of excluding meat. This explains why simply being vegetarian or vegan does not guarantee a mortality benefit: the quality of the plant foods matters enormously.
Summary on mortality
The evidence on mortality is less clear‑cut than on intermediate risk factors. The most optimistic estimates (from AHS‑2) suggest a 10–20% reduction in all‑cause mortality for vegetarians, particularly pescetarians. The more conservative estimates (from EPIC‑Oxford) suggest no significant difference. Meta‑analyses tend to find small, non‑significant reductions for all‑cause mortality but a possible benefit for ischaemic heart disease mortality.
What is not in dispute is that plant‑based diets that are *high in quality* – rich in whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, and legumes – are associated with lower mortality compared to typical Western diets. The debate centres on whether the exclusion of all animal foods (veganism) or most animal foods (vegetarianism) confers additional benefit beyond simply eating a high‑quality, plant‑rich diet. This question remains open and likely depends on the specific population, the quality of the plant foods consumed, and the adequacy of micronutrient intake – particularly vitamin B12, iron, calcium, and omega‑3 fatty acids.
In the next section, we will turn from mortality to the gut microbiome – a rapidly evolving area of research that offers mechanistic insights into how different diets might influence health at the microbial level.
4. Microbiome and inflammation: under the hood of digestion
The gut microbiome – the community of trillions of bacteria, archaea, fungi, and viruses residing in the human intestinal tract – has emerged as a key mediator of the relationship between diet and health. Dietary patterns shape the composition and function of the gut microbiota, and these microbial communities, in turn, influence host metabolism, immune function, and even neurological processes. In this section, we examine how vegetarian, vegan, and omnivorous diets leave distinct microbial “signatures” and whether these differences translate into meaningful differences in inflammatory markers.
4.1. Microbial signatures of dietary patterns
The most comprehensive recent study on this topic comes from Fackelmann and colleagues (2025), who analysed gut metagenomes from 21,561 individuals across five independent cohorts (three from the ZOE PREDICT programme in the UK and US, plus two smaller Italian cohorts). Participants were classified as omnivore, vegetarian, or vegan based on self‑reported dietary habits, and their gut microbiomes were profiled using shotgun metagenomic sequencing.
Distinct microbial profiles
The study found that microbial profiles could distinguish between the three dietary patterns with high accuracy. Using machine learning classifiers (random forests) in a cross‑validation design that left one entire cohort out for testing, the mean area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) across all diet patterns and cohorts was 0.85 – indicating good discriminative ability. The highest predictability was achieved when separating vegans from omnivores (mean cross‑LODO AUC = 0.90), followed by vegetarians from vegans (0.84), and finally vegetarians from omnivores (0.82) (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
The imperfect classification (AUC < 1.00) likely reflects several factors: individuals may have changed their diet recently, there is individual variation in microbial responses to diet, and some overlap in microbial communities between diet groups is expected. Nevertheless, the results demonstrate that long‑term dietary patterns leave a detectable and reproducible imprint on the gut microbiome.
Omnivore‑associated microbes
When the researchers examined which specific microbial species (or species‑level genome bins, SGBs) were differentially abundant between diet groups, striking patterns emerged. Omnivore microbiomes were enriched for several species that have been previously linked to meat consumption, protein fermentation, and inflammatory conditions.
- Alistipes putredinis: This species is involved in protein fermentation and has been associated with meat‑rich diets. It can produce potentially harmful metabolites from aromatic amino acids.
- Bilophila wadsworthia: A sulfidogenic bacterium that thrives on high‑fat, high‑animal‑protein diets. It produces hydrogen sulfide, which can damage the intestinal epithelial barrier and promote inflammation. Bilophila wadsworthia has been implicated in inflammatory bowel disease and metabolic dysfunction in animal models (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
- Ruminococcus torques: A mucolytic bacterium that degrades the intestinal mucus layer. Increased abundance of Ruminococcus torques has been observed in inflammatory bowel disease and is considered a marker of gut barrier dysfunction.
These three species were among the top 30 microbial markers distinguishing omnivores from vegetarians and vegans. Importantly, their relative abundances correlated positively with red meat consumption (more strongly than with white meat) and negatively with the intake of fruits, vegetables, and healthy plant‑based foods (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
Vegetarian‑ and vegan‑associated microbes
In contrast, vegetarian and vegan microbiomes were enriched for species that are known producers of short‑chain fatty acids (SCFAs), particularly butyrate. Butyrate is the primary energy source for colonocytes, strengthens the gut barrier, and has anti‑inflammatory properties.
- Lachnospiraceae (multiple SGBs): This large family of Firmicutes is highly specialised in degrading dietary fibre and resistant starch, producing butyrate as a fermentation end‑product.
- Roseburia hominis: A butyrate‑producing species that has been associated with improved insulin sensitivity and reduced inflammation. Lower abundances of Roseburia have been reported in patients with type 2 diabetes and inflammatory bowel disease.
- Butyricicoccus species: Another butyrate producer that may support intestinal epithelial integrity.
These SGBs were significantly overrepresented in vegan and, to a lesser extent, vegetarian gut microbiomes. Their abundances correlated positively with fruit and vegetable intake and with the healthful Plant‑Based Diet Index (hPDI) (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
Dairy‑associated microbes
An intriguing finding concerned Streptococcus thermophilus, a bacterium widely used as a starter culture in yogurt and cheese production. Streptococcus thermophilus had the highest effect size in differentiating vegetarian from vegan gut microbiomes (standardised mean difference = –0.67, favouring vegetarians) and the second‑highest effect size in differentiating omnivore from vegan microbiomes (SMD = –0.62). In other words, this dairy‑associated bacterium was much more abundant in individuals who consumed dairy products (omnivores and vegetarians) than in vegans.
Other lactic acid bacteria – Lactobacillus acidophilus, Lactobacillus delbrueckii, Lactococcus lactis, Lacticaseibacillus paracasei, and Lacticaseibacillus rhamnosus – showed similar patterns. These microbes are common in fermented dairy products (yogurt, kefir, cheese) and are also used as probiotics. Their presence in the gut microbiome of dairy consumers likely reflects both transient passage from food and, in some cases, possible colonisation.
Fackelmann and colleagues (2025) concluded that while some dairy‑associated microbes may be selected to help digest dairy (e.g., through lactose fermentation), others are likely present as transient members derived directly from dairy foods themselves. The much lower prevalence of these bacteria in vegans was striking: for example, Streptococcus thermophilus was detected in the majority of omnivores and vegetarians but in only a small fraction of vegans (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
Soil‑associated microbes in vegans
Unexpectedly, vegan gut microbiomes showed higher prevalence of several bacteria typically associated with soil and plant environments: Enterobacter hormaechei, Citrobacter freundii, Raoultella ornithinolytica, and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Some strains of these species are known to promote plant growth through nitrogen fixation or phytohormone production. For example, Enterobacter hormaechei has been used as a plant growth‑promoting bacterium in tomatoes and sweet peppers, and certain strains of Klebsiella pneumoniae are nitrogen fixers used as biofertilisers in wheat and soybeans (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
The presence of these environmental bacteria in vegan guts suggests that agricultural practices – and direct consumption of fresh produce with its adherent soil microbes – may contribute to the gut microbiome. However, the researchers caution that some of these species are also opportunistic pathogens in immunocompromised hosts, and their health implications are not yet clear. This finding opens an intriguing but still‑unexplored avenue: the role of soil microbes in the human gut, particularly in individuals with high intake of raw or minimally processed plant foods.
Absence of expected signals
Interestingly, the study did not find species from the Segatella copri complex (formerly Prevotella copri) as strong signatures of vegetarian or vegan diets, despite previous hypotheses that Segatella copri is enriched in fibre‑rich, non‑Westernised populations (Fackelmann et al., 2025). The reasons for this absence are unclear but may relate to the specific populations studied (predominantly high‑income, Western countries) or to methodological differences in taxonomic profiling.
Functional implications
Beyond taxonomic composition, Fackelmann and colleagues (2025) also examined microbial metabolic pathways. Vegan and vegetarian gut metagenomes were enriched for plant‑associated pathways, including the degradation of inositols (myo‑, chiro‑, and scyllo‑inositol degradation pathway PWY‑7237) – molecules that are abundant carbon and energy sources in plant‑associated environments. These pathways are widespread in soil and rhizosphere bacteria and may provide a competitive advantage for microbes in plant‑rich niches.
Omnivore gut metagenomes, in contrast, were enriched for pathways involved in the breakdown of animal‑derived foods and amino acid metabolism, including the superpathway of L‑threonine biosynthesis (THRESYN) and the superpathway of L‑serine and glycine biosynthesis (SER‑GLYSYN). Omnivore microbiomes also showed a greater capacity for salvaging essential cofactors abundant in animal foods, such as adenosylcobalamin (vitamin B12) from dietary precursors – a pathway absent in vegan metagenomes (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
Summary
The gut microbiome carries a clear signature of long‑term dietary patterns. Omnivore microbiomes are enriched for species linked to meat fermentation, mucus degradation, and potential inflammation (Alistipes putredinis, Bilophila wadsworthia, Ruminococcus torques). Vegetarian and vegan microbiomes are enriched for butyrate‑producing fibre degraders (Lachnospiraceae, Roseburia, Butyricicoccus). Dairy consumers harbour lactic acid bacteria from fermented products, while vegans show higher prevalence of soil‑associated environmental bacteria. These differences are not merely taxonomic – they extend to metabolic pathways that reflect the dietary niche of the host.
In the next subsection, we will examine whether these microbial differences translate into measurable differences in systemic inflammation – and whether the lower omega‑3 status of plant‑based eaters counteracts the anti‑inflammatory potential of their fibre‑rich diet.
4.2. Biomarkers of inflammation
The gut microbiome influences systemic inflammation through multiple mechanisms. Bacterial cell wall components (lipopolysaccharide, LPS) can translocate across a compromised intestinal barrier and trigger low‑grade inflammation. Short‑chain fatty acids (SCFAs) produced by fibre‑fermenting bacteria, particularly butyrate, have anti‑inflammatory effects and strengthen the gut barrier. And the balance of omega‑6 and omega‑3 fatty acids influences the production of pro‑inflammatory and anti‑inflammatory eicosanoids.
Given that plant‑based diets are rich in fibre and polyphenols (which may support anti‑inflammatory bacteria) but also have lower levels of long‑chain omega‑3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), it is not obvious a priori whether vegetarians and vegans have lower, higher, or similar levels of inflammatory markers compared to omnivores. The evidence, summarised below, provides a nuanced answer.
C‑reactive protein (CRP)
C‑reactive protein is the most commonly measured marker of low‑grade systemic inflammation. It is produced by the liver in response to interleukin‑6 (IL‑6) and other inflammatory cytokines, and elevated CRP is a strong predictor of future cardiovascular events.
A systematic review and meta‑analysis by Menzel and colleagues (2020) – cited in Grammatikopoulou et al. (2025) – examined the associations of vegan and vegetarian diets with inflammatory biomarkers. The authors found that vegan diets were associated with significantly lower CRP concentrations compared to omnivores. The association was weaker and less consistent for vegetarian diets. When all plant‑based dietary patterns were pooled, they were associated with lower CRP, fibrinogen, and total leukocyte concentrations compared to non‑vegetarian patterns (Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
However, the authors noted that the evidence from intervention studies was insufficient for meta‑analysis, and the observational findings were subject to residual confounding. Moreover, the effect sizes were modest.
The NuEva study (Klein et al., 2025) – a cross‑sectional study of 252 healthy German adults – found that hsCRP (high‑sensitivity CRP) levels did not differ significantly between omnivores, flexitarians, vegetarians, and vegans. There was a trend toward lower hsCRP in vegans compared to omnivores and flexitarians (p = 0.09), but this did not reach statistical significance. The authors suggested that the lack of significant differences might be due to the healthy nature of their study population, in whom inflammatory markers were already low.
Interleukins and tumour necrosis factor (TNF‑α)
The picture for other inflammatory cytokines is even less clear. In the NuEva study, levels of IL‑6, IL‑8, IL‑10, and TNF‑α did not differ significantly between any of the dietary groups (Klein et al., 2025). Similarly, a systematic review by Craddock and colleagues (2019) – cited in Grammatikopoulou et al. (2025) – found no consistent effect of vegetarian diets on IL‑6 or TNF‑α.
These null findings are perhaps surprising, given the clear differences in gut microbial composition between diet groups and the known anti‑inflammatory properties of butyrate. Several explanations are possible.
First, the inflammatory markers measured in blood reflect systemic inflammation, which may be influenced by many factors beyond the gut microbiome – including adiposity, physical activity, smoking, and stress. In healthy, relatively lean, non‑smoking, physically active individuals (which characterises many vegetarian and vegan study participants), baseline inflammation may already be low, leaving little room for further reduction.
Second, the lower EPA and DHA status of vegetarians and vegans might offset some of the anti‑inflammatory benefits of a high‑fibre diet. Long‑chain omega‑3 fatty acids are substrates for specialised pro‑resolving mediators (resolvins, protectins, maresins) that actively resolve inflammation. Without adequate EPA and DHA, the inflammatory resolution phase may be impaired – even if the initiation phase is not exaggerated.
Third, the relationship between diet and systemic inflammation is complex and likely non‑linear. Small changes in individual inflammatory markers may not be statistically detectable in moderate‑sized studies, yet they could still have clinical significance over decades. Conversely, the absence of differences in these markers does not rule out beneficial effects of plant‑based diets on other health outcomes that are not primarily driven by systemic inflammation.
Adipokines: leptin and adiponectin
Adipose tissue produces several signalling molecules that influence inflammation and metabolism. Leptin is generally pro‑inflammatory and increases with adiposity; adiponectin is anti‑inflammatory and decreases with obesity.
In the NuEva study, vegans had significantly lower leptin levels compared to omnivores (Klein et al., 2025). This is likely explained by their lower body fat percentage – leptin correlates strongly with fat mass. Adiponectin levels did not differ between groups, nor did the adiponectin/leptin ratio.
These findings suggest that the lower body weight and body fat of vegetarians and vegans – rather than a direct effect of plant foods on adipokine secretion – may be the primary driver of differences in leptin. Since obesity itself is a major inflammatory stimulus, any dietary pattern that supports healthy weight management will indirectly lower inflammation.
Putting the evidence together
When interpreting the literature on inflammatory markers and plant‑based diets, several principles are useful.
1. The healthy population problem. Most studies recruit generally healthy individuals. In such populations, inflammatory markers are often already within the normal range. Detecting differences between diet groups requires large sample sizes and careful control of confounders. The modest or null findings in many studies may reflect limited statistical power rather than true equivalence.
2. The distinction between vegan and vegetarian. The evidence for lower CRP is stronger for vegans than for vegetarians. This may reflect the lower saturated fat intake, higher fibre intake, or lower body weight of vegans compared to even lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians.
3. The importance of diet quality. As discussed in Section 5, not all plant‑based diets are equal. An “unhealthful” plant‑based diet – high in refined grains, sweets, and sugar‑sweetened beverages – could be pro‑inflammatory despite excluding meat. Studies that fail to account for plant food quality may miss important associations.
4. The omega‑3 trade‑off. The lower EPA and DHA status of vegetarians and vegans is a genuine concern. While the clinical significance for healthy young adults is uncertain, it may become more important during periods of high physiological demand (pregnancy, infancy, ageing) or in individuals with genetic variants that impair ALA conversion. Some researchers recommend that vegans consider microalgae‑derived DHA supplements (Klein et al., 2025).
Summary
The evidence on systemic inflammatory markers and plant‑based diets is mixed. Observational studies often report lower CRP in vegans (and to a lesser extent vegetarians), but intervention studies are lacking and many cross‑sectional studies find no significant differences in IL‑6, IL‑10, or TNF‑α. The lower leptin levels in vegans are largely explained by their lower body fat. The absence of strong, consistent differences in inflammatory markers does not negate the clear benefits of plant‑based diets for blood lipids, blood pressure, and diabetes risk – but it does suggest that the anti‑inflammatory effects of plant‑based diets may be modest in healthy, lean populations, and that the lower omega‑3 status of vegans warrants attention.
In the next section, we will move beyond simple comparisons of “vegetarian versus omnivore” to examine the critical concept of diet quality – showing that the health effects of a plant‑based diet depend not only on what is excluded (meat, dairy, eggs) but also on what is included and how those plant foods are prepared and processed.
5. The quality of plant‑based diets: not all vegetarianism is equally beneficial
Up to this point, we have compared dietary patterns primarily on the basis of what they exclude: meat, fish, dairy, or eggs. This approach – classifying people as omnivores, vegetarians, or vegans – is convenient and widely used, but it has a fundamental limitation. Two individuals following a “vegetarian” diet could have dramatically different health profiles: one might eat whole grains, legumes, vegetables, fruits, nuts, and seeds; the other might rely on white bread, French fries, fruit juices, sweets, and sugar‑sweetened beverages. Both are technically vegetarian, but their health outcomes are likely to be very different.
This problem is not unique to plant‑based diets. Among omnivores, the difference between a Mediterranean diet and a fast‑food‑based Western diet is well recognised. But in the context of plant‑based eating, the failure to distinguish between healthful and unhealthful plant foods has led to confusion and contradictory findings. A growing body of research now shows that the quality of plant foods matters as much as – and sometimes more than – the absence of animal foods (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
5.1. The concept of hPDI (healthful) and uPDI (unhealthful) plant‑based dietary indices
To address this limitation, researchers led by Satija and colleagues (2016) – as described in Rosenfeld et al. (2023) – developed the Plant‑Based Dietary Index (PDI) and its two sub‑indices: the healthful PDI (hPDI) and the unhealthful PDI (uPDI). These indices are calculated from food frequency questionnaires and provide a continuous score reflecting the quality of a person’s plant‑based diet, rather than simply whether they eat meat or not.
The construction of these indices is straightforward and intuitive:
- Overall PDI gives higher scores for higher intake of all plant foods (both healthy and less healthy) and lower intake of animal foods. It does not distinguish between a whole grain and a sugary cereal – both count as “plant foods”.
- hPDI (healthful) gives higher scores for higher intake of healthy plant foods (whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, vegetable oils, tea/coffee) and lower intake of less healthy plant foods (refined grains, fruit juices, potatoes, sweets, sugar‑sweetened beverages) and all animal foods.
- uPDI (unhealthful) gives higher scores for higher intake of less healthy plant foods, lower intake of healthy plant foods, and lower intake of animal foods. In other words, a person who eats many refined grains, sweets, and sugary drinks – but avoids meat – would score high on uPDI.
This distinction has proved to be remarkably powerful. Rosenfeld and colleagues (2023) conducted a scoping review of 95 articles that used the PDI, hPDI, or uPDI to assess associations with health outcomes. Their findings, summarised across tens of thousands of participants, were striking.
Healthful plant‑based diet (hPDI) is consistently associated with better health.
Across all comparisons, higher hPDI scores were associated with favourable health outcomes in 36% of the statistical tests (compared to only 25% for the overall PDI and just 2% for the uPDI). Favourable associations were most frequent for psychiatric disorders (94% of comparisons), diabetes (64%), cardiovascular disease (45%), mortality (43%), and obesity (42%). Notably, higher hPDI was almost never associated with unfavourable outcomes (only 0.4% of comparisons) (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
Unhealthful plant‑based diet (uPDI) is consistently associated with worse health.
In contrast, higher uPDI scores were associated with unfavourable health outcomes in 33% of comparisons – most frequently for psychiatric disorders (50%), mortality (39%), obesity (36%), and cardiometabolic risk factors (31%). Favourable associations with uPDI were extremely rare (2% of comparisons) (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
Concordance and discordance between indices.
When the hPDI and the overall PDI were compared in the same study, their results were concordant (both pointing in the same direction) in 70% of comparisons. But when they were discordant, the findings always favoured the hPDI over the uPDI, and nearly always favoured the hPDI over the overall PDI. In other words, using a simple plant‑versus‑animal classification (PDI) can obscure or dilute the true health benefits of a high‑quality plant‑based diet (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
Why does this matter for vegetarians and vegans?
Many people assume that “plant‑based” automatically means “healthy”. The hPDI/uPDI framework shows that this is not true. A vegetarian who consumes large amounts of refined grains (white bread, white rice, pasta), fruit juices, sweets, and sugar‑sweetened beverages – while avoiding meat – may have a health profile no better than, or even worse than, a moderate omnivore who eats small amounts of meat but also consumes plenty of whole plant foods.
Conversely, an omnivore who follows a Mediterranean‑style diet – rich in whole grains, vegetables, fruits, legumes, nuts, and fish – may have health outcomes comparable to or better than a vegetarian who eats a low‑quality plant‑based diet (Riera et al., 2025). The key is the overall dietary pattern, not the simple presence or absence of meat.
Examples from the literature
The ENRICA study, a large Spanish cohort, directly compared the Planetary Health Diet Index (PHDI) and the Mediterranean Diet score (MEDAS) – both of which emphasise high‑quality plant foods. Higher adherence to either index was associated with approximately 21–22% lower all‑cause mortality over 14 years of follow‑up (Riera et al., 2025). Notably, the beneficial associations were driven by specific food components: higher intake of fruits, nuts, and unsaturated oils, and lower consumption of red meat, processed meat, sugar‑sweetened beverages, and commercial baked goods.
In the Adventist Health Study‑2, vegetarians who consumed higher amounts of whole grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds – i.e., a high‑hPDI pattern – had lower mortality than vegetarians whose plant food intake was of lower quality (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). The message is clear: what you eat within a vegetarian framework matters enormously.
Implications for interpreting research
The hPDI/uPDI framework has several important implications for how we interpret studies on plant‑based diets.
First, it explains why some studies find only modest or null effects of vegetarianism on health outcomes. If a study does not account for the quality of plant foods, it may be mixing together two very different exposures: a high‑quality vegetarian diet (which is beneficial) and a low‑quality vegetarian diet (which is neutral or harmful). The average effect may be diluted.
Second, it highlights the importance of moving beyond binary classifications. Future research should routinely report both overall PDI and hPDI/uPDI scores, or at least provide information on the types of plant foods consumed.
Third, it has practical implications for public health messaging. Encouraging people to “eat more plants” is not enough. They need guidance on which plants to eat: whole grains rather than refined grains, whole fruits rather than fruit juices, water rather than sugar‑sweetened beverages, and a variety of legumes, nuts, and seeds.
Limitations of the hPDI/uPDI approach
The hPDI and uPDI are not without limitations. The classification of some foods as “healthy” or “unhealthy” may vary by context. Potatoes, for example, are classified as less healthy in the original Satija scheme, but boiled or baked potatoes with skin can be a nutritious source of potassium and fibre; the problem is primarily with fried potatoes (French fries, crisps) and potatoes prepared with large amounts of fat and salt. Similarly, fruit juices are classified as less healthy, but 100% fruit juice without added sugar is less problematic than sugar‑sweetened fruit drinks. However, for large‑scale epidemiological studies, these simplifications are necessary and have proven useful.
Another limitation is that the indices do not directly measure food processing. An ultra‑processed plant‑based burger may be made from pea protein and be technically “plant‑based”, but its health effects may differ substantially from a minimally processed legume dish. Emerging research on food processing (e.g., the NOVA classification) suggests that this is an important dimension that complements the hPDI/uPDI approach.
Summary
The quality of plant foods is not a minor footnote – it is central to the health effects of plant‑based diets. The hPDI and uPDI indices provide a powerful tool for distinguishing between healthful and unhealthful plant‑based eating patterns. A high‑quality plant‑based diet – rich in whole grains, fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, seeds, and unsaturated oils – is associated with lower mortality, lower diabetes risk, better cardiovascular health, and better mental health outcomes. A low‑quality plant‑based diet – high in refined grains, sweets, fruit juices, and sugar‑sweetened beverages – offers no such benefits and may even be harmful.
In the next subsection, we will apply this framework to compare vegetarian and Western diets directly, showing how the quality dimension changes the conclusions one might draw from simple meat‑versus‑no‑meat comparisons.
5.2. Comparing vegetarian and Western diets through the lens of hPDI/uPDI
Armed with the hPDI and uPDI framework, we can now revisit the comparison between vegetarian and Western (omnivore) diets in a more nuanced way. The traditional binary comparison – “vegetarians are healthier than omnivores” or vice versa – is too crude. It conflates two separate questions: (1) does excluding meat and animal products confer health benefits? and (2) does eating a high‑quality, plant‑rich diet confer health benefits? The hPDI/uPDI approach allows us to disentangle these questions.
Vegetarian diets are not a monolith
As shown in Section 5.1, a vegetarian can have a high hPDI score (if they eat plenty of whole grains, fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, and seeds) or a high uPDI score (if they rely on refined grains, sweets, fruit juices, and sugary drinks). In large epidemiological studies, the average effect of “vegetarianism” hides this variation. When researchers have sufficient data to calculate hPDI and uPDI separately within vegetarian populations, a clear pattern emerges: the health benefits are concentrated in those with high hPDI scores, while vegetarians with high uPDI scores have outcomes no better than – and sometimes worse than – omnivores (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
The Western diet as a comparator
The typical Western diet is characterised by high intakes of red and processed meat, refined grains, sweets, sugar‑sweetened beverages, and often low intakes of whole plant foods. Its hPDI score is generally low, and its uPDI score is generally high. When compared to a high‑quality vegetarian diet (high hPDI), the Western diet performs poorly on virtually all health outcomes: higher LDL cholesterol, higher blood pressure, higher diabetes risk, higher mortality. This is the comparison that has shaped much of the public perception that vegetarianism is “healthy”.
However, when the comparator is a low‑quality vegetarian diet (high uPDI), the picture changes. Such a diet – rich in refined carbohydrates, sugars, and low in fibre – may be no better than the Western diet, and for some outcomes (e.g., triglycerides, HDL cholesterol, metabolic syndrome) it could even be worse (Rosenfeld et al., 2023; Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
The flexitarian and Mediterranean alternatives
The hPDI/uPDI framework also helps explain why flexitarian and Mediterranean diets – which include small amounts of animal foods but are rich in high‑quality plant foods – often show health benefits comparable to or greater than those of strict vegetarianism. In the ENRICA study, adherence to the Mediterranean diet (MEDAS score) was associated with a 21% reduction in all‑cause mortality – nearly identical to the 22% reduction for the Planetary Health Diet Index (PHDI), both of which emphasise high‑quality plant foods (Riera et al., 2025). Importantly, both indices reward the consumption of whole grains, fruits, vegetables, nuts, legumes, and unsaturated oils, and penalise red meat, processed meat, and sugary products. The presence of small amounts of fish, poultry, or dairy in the Mediterranean pattern does not negate the benefits, as long as the overall quality of plant foods remains high.
What about the “unhealthful” omnivore?
Conversely, an omnivore who follows a high‑hPDI pattern – that is, someone who eats small amounts of meat or fish but also consumes large quantities of whole grains, legumes, vegetables, fruits, nuts, and seeds – may have health outcomes that are very similar to those of a high‑hPDI vegetarian. The crucial factor is not the binary presence or absence of meat, but the overall dietary quality. This is consistent with the finding that pescetarians in AHS‑2 had the lowest all‑cause mortality among all diet groups – even lower than vegans (Orlich & Fraser, 2014). Pescetarians typically consume fish (a source of long‑chain omega‑3s) along with a plant‑rich diet; their hPDI scores are likely high.
Practical implications for individuals
For an individual considering a dietary change, the hPDI/uPDI framework offers practical guidance:
- If you are currently a typical Western omnivore (low hPDI, high uPDI), moving towards a high‑quality plant‑based diet – whether vegetarian, pescetarian, or flexitarian – is likely to improve your health. The key changes are: increase whole grains, fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, seeds; decrease red and processed meat; decrease refined grains, sweets, and sugary drinks.
- If you are already a vegetarian but your diet is low in whole plant foods and high in refined carbohydrates and sweets, simply removing meat is not enough. You need to improve the *quality* of your plant foods. Switching from white bread to whole grain bread, from fruit juice to whole fruit, and from sugary snacks to nuts or seeds can substantially improve your hPDI score and, by extension, your health outcomes.
- If you are a vegan, the same principle applies. A vegan diet can be either very healthy (rich in whole grains, legumes, vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds) or quite unhealthy (rich in refined grains, vegan sweets, sugary drinks, and highly processed meat analogues). The hPDI/uPDI distinction applies equally within veganism.
Limitations of applying hPDI/uPDI to diet comparisons
While powerful, the hPDI/uPDI framework has some limitations when comparing vegetarian and Western diets. First, the indices were developed and validated primarily in Western populations; their applicability to other cultural contexts is uncertain. Second, the classification of certain foods (e.g., potatoes, fruit juice) as “less healthy” may be context‑dependent. Third, the indices do not capture food processing intensity, which may be independently important. A minimally processed plant‑based diet is likely superior to an ultra‑processed one, even if both have similar hPDI scores.
Summary
Comparing vegetarian and Western diets through the lens of hPDI/uPDI reveals that the binary question “Is vegetarianism healthier?” is poorly framed. The more useful questions are: “What is the quality of the plant foods consumed?” and “What is being eaten instead of meat?”. A high‑quality vegetarian diet (high hPDI) is clearly associated with better health outcomes than a typical Western diet. A low‑quality vegetarian diet (high uPDI) offers little advantage. And omnivorous diets that are rich in high‑quality plant foods (high hPDI) can be just as beneficial as vegetarian diets. The focus should shift from excluding animal products to including a wide variety of minimally processed, nutrient‑dense plant foods – while reducing or eliminating red and processed meat, refined grains, and sugary products. This message is consistent across dietary patterns and is supported by the large body of research reviewed in this article.
6. Economic affordability: what does healthy eating cost?
Throughout this article, we have focused on nutritional composition, health outcomes, and microbial signatures. But there is another dimension that is often overlooked in discussions of plant‑based diets: cost. For many individuals and families, food choices are constrained not only by knowledge and preferences but also by budget. A diet that is nutritionally adequate and environmentally sustainable is of little use if it is unaffordable to a large segment of the population.
The question of affordability cuts both ways. Some argue that plant‑based diets are cheaper because they rely on staples like grains, beans, and seasonal vegetables. Others contend that high‑quality plant foods – fresh produce, nuts, seeds, and fortified products – can be expensive, and that animal foods provide essential nutrients at a lower cost per unit of bioavailable nutrient. Who is right? The evidence from economic modelling studies provides a nuanced answer (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
Modelling least‑cost nutritionally adequate diets
One powerful approach to studying diet affordability is linear programming (LP). LP is a mathematical optimisation technique that identifies the combination of foods that meets all specified nutrient requirements at the lowest possible cost, given a set of food prices and availability constraints. LP does not necessarily produce a palatable or culturally acceptable diet, but it reveals the economic minimum – the theoretical lower bound of what a nutritionally adequate diet would cost.
Chungchunlam and Moughan (2024) used LP to model least‑cost diets for healthy adults in two high‑income countries: the United States (using 2009–2010 national food prices) and New Zealand (using 2020 prices). They also conducted preliminary modelling in Indonesia, a lower‑middle‑income country. The nutrient requirements were based on dietary reference intakes (estimated average requirements or recommended dietary allowances) for adults aged 19–50 years.
Least‑cost diets in the United States and New Zealand
In both the US and New Zealand, the baseline least‑cost nutritionally adequate diet – the cheapest possible combination of foods that meets energy, protein, essential fatty acid, vitamin, and mineral requirements – included animal‑sourced foods.
- United States: The least‑cost diet cost US $1.98 per day (2009–2010 prices) and comprised 15 foods. Animal‑sourced foods in the solution included dairy milk, eggs, and fish. The largest contributors to diet cost were milk (26%), fortified breakfast cereals (14.2%), potatoes (12.6%), and legumes (12.4%). Fats and oils (margarine, mayonnaise) contributed the least (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
- New Zealand: The least‑cost diet cost NZ $3.23 per day (2020 prices; approximately US $2.14) and also included dairy milk, eggs, and seafood. The main cost contributors were legumes (29%), milk (21%), and seeds (13%) (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
These results show that, under current market conditions in two developed economies, excluding all animal foods would increase the cost of meeting nutrient requirements, not decrease it. Animal‑sourced foods – particularly milk and eggs – are economically efficient sources of several essential nutrients, including high‑quality protein, calcium, vitamin B12, and bioavailable iron and zinc.
What does it take to exclude all animal foods?
To model a plant‑only (vegan) least‑cost diet, Chungchunlam and Moughan (2024) progressively increased the prices of all animal‑sourced foods in the LP model until the optimal solution no longer included any animal products. The magnitude of price increases required was substantial:
- United States: The prices of selected animal foods had to be increased by 2.0‑ to 11.5‑fold above baseline. For example, egg prices needed to increase 11.5 times, fish 6.5 times, milk 8.0 times. The resulting plant‑only diet cost US $3.61 per day – 45% more expensive than the baseline mixed diet (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
- New Zealand: Required price increases ranged from 1.05‑ to 10.3‑fold. The plant‑only diet cost NZ $4.34 per day (US $2.87) – 34% more expensive than the mixed diet (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
The plant‑only diets in both countries relied heavily on fortified foods, particularly fortified soymilk. In the US plant‑only solution, fortified soymilk contributed 37% of total diet cost; in New Zealand, it contributed 47%. Without fortification, it would have been impossible to meet vitamin B12 requirements (and, in some cases, calcium and vitamin D requirements) from unfortified plant foods alone.
First‑limiting nutrients in plant‑only diets
The LP models also identified which nutrients were “first‑limiting” – that is, the nutrients that constrained the optimisation and drove the inclusion of specific foods.
In the baseline mixed diets (containing animal foods), the first‑limiting nutrients were generally vitamins and minerals: calcium, potassium, selenium, vitamin A, vitamin C, vitamin D, and vitamin E. These were met by a combination of plant and animal foods.
In the plant‑only diets, additional nutrients became limiting or more difficult to meet:
- Vitamin B12 – impossible to obtain from unfortified plant foods; required fortified soymilk.
- Zinc – harder to meet because of lower bioavailability from plant sources.
- Pantothenic acid (vitamin B5) – became a binding constraint.
- Calcium and vitamin D – required fortified plant milks.
The protein quality of the plant‑only diet was also lower. Using the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS), the plant‑only diet scored 76% (against the FAO adult reference pattern) and only 62% (against the more stringent young child pattern), compared to 120% and 95% for the mixed diet (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024). In practical terms, the plant‑only diet provided less utilizable protein and a less balanced amino acid profile, particularly for lysine and the sulfur‑containing amino acids.
Implications for low‑ and middle‑income countries
The LP modelling in the US and New Zealand reflects high‑income food economies, where animal foods are relatively affordable and plant‑based fortified products are available. The situation in low‑ and middle‑income countries (LMICs) may be different – but not necessarily in the direction often assumed.
Preliminary modelling in Indonesia (a lower‑middle‑income country) by the same research group found that the least‑cost nutritionally adequate diet also included animal‑sourced foods – specifically dairy milk, chicken liver, and clams. These foods were needed to meet requirements for calcium, sodium, potassium, and vitamin A at the lowest cost. The daily diet cost was approximately Rp 16,189 (US $1.09) (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
In many LMICs, however, animal foods are relatively more expensive than in high‑income countries, and fortified plant‑based products may not be widely available or affordable. This raises a critical concern: promoting strict plant‑based diets in populations with limited access to fortified foods or supplements could worsen nutritional deficiencies, particularly for vitamin B12, iron, zinc, and calcium. The affordability of a nutritionally adequate diet – whether plant‑based or mixed – is a major public health issue that cannot be ignored.
Limitations of LP modelling for affordability
LP modelling has important limitations. First, it assumes that individuals can and will eat any combination of foods, ignoring taste preferences, culinary traditions, and social acceptability. A diet that is mathematically optimal but unpalatable is not a realistic recommendation. Second, LP uses average national food prices, which mask regional and seasonal variation. Third, it does not account for food waste, cooking fuel, or the time cost of food preparation. Fourth, it assumes perfect knowledge of nutrient composition and requirements, which is not true in practice.
Nevertheless, LP provides a valuable benchmark: the minimum cost at which a nutritionally adequate diet could theoretically be achieved. If this minimum is already unaffordable for a large fraction of the population, then realistic, culturally acceptable diets will be even more expensive.
Affordability of the EAT‑Lancet planetary health diet
The EAT‑Lancet reference diet – a predominantly plant‑based diet designed to be both healthy and environmentally sustainable – has been analysed for global affordability. A 2020 study (cited in Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024) estimated that the EAT‑Lancet diet would cost a global median of US $2.84 per day (2011 prices, purchasing power parity adjusted). This exceeds the per capita food expenditure of approximately 1.6 billion people worldwide. In other words, for nearly 20% of the global population, even the cheapest version of the EAT‑Lancet diet is unaffordable.
The same study found that the cost of a nutritionally adequate least‑cost diet (not necessarily following EAT‑Lancet guidelines) was substantially lower – a global median of US $1.35 per day (2011 prices). The gap between the least‑cost adequate diet and the EAT‑Lancet diet reflects the additional cost of shifting to a more sustainable but more restrictive pattern (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
Practical takeaways
- Under current market conditions in high‑income countries, the cheapest way to meet all nutrient requirements includes animal foods – particularly milk, eggs, and fish. Excluding all animal foods increases diet cost by 34–45% and requires reliance on fortified products.
- Plant‑only diets can be nutritionally adequate, but only if carefully planned and, in practice, fortified. Unfortified vegan diets are almost certain to be deficient in vitamin B12 and may be low in calcium, zinc, iodine, and long‑chain omega‑3s.
- Affordability matters for public health. Promoting plant‑based diets without considering economic constraints risks creating two tiers of nutrition: those who can afford high‑quality, well‑planned plant‑based diets (with fortified products and supplements) and those who cannot, and may suffer deficiencies.
- The most affordable nutritionally adequate diet for a given population will depend on local food prices, food availability, and food culture. There is no single global “cheapest diet”.
Summary
Economic affordability is a critical but often neglected dimension of sustainable healthy diets. In the US and New Zealand, the least‑cost nutritionally adequate diet includes animal foods (milk, eggs, fish). Excluding all animal foods requires substantial price increases for animal products (2‑ to 11‑fold) and results in a diet that is 34–45% more expensive, heavily reliant on fortified soymilk, and of lower protein quality. In lower‑income countries, the affordability gap is even更大, and promoting strict plant‑based diets without ensuring access to fortified foods or supplements could exacerbate malnutrition. Any realistic discussion of dietary change for health or environmental reasons must include the question: can people afford it? For many, the answer today is no – and that is a problem that policy, not individual choice alone, must address.
Conclusion
This article has taken a comparative journey through the landscape of dietary patterns, from unrestricted omnivore diets to strict veganism, with vegetarianism occupying a central position along the continuum. We have examined how these diets differ in their nutrient profiles, their associations with cardiometabolic markers, their signatures in the gut microbiome, and – perhaps most importantly – the critical role of plant food quality in determining health outcomes.
Several clear conclusions emerge from the evidence reviewed.
First, vegetarian diets are not a single entity. Depending on what is included (whole grains vs. refined grains, legumes vs. sweets, nuts vs. fruit juices) and what is excluded (dairy, eggs, or only meat), the health effects of a vegetarian diet can range from highly beneficial to neutral or even adverse. The distinction between healthful (hPDI) and unhealthful (uPDI) plant‑based diets is not a minor technical detail – it is central to understanding the relationship between plant‑based eating and human health (Rosenfeld et al., 2023).
Second, compared to a typical Western omnivore diet, a well‑planned vegetarian diet is associated with multiple favourable health indicators. These include lower total and LDL cholesterol, lower blood pressure, lower risk of type 2 diabetes, lower prevalence of metabolic syndrome, and a gut microbiome enriched in butyrate‑producing fibre degraders (Fackelmann et al., 2025; Orlich & Fraser, 2014; Leite et al., 2020). The magnitude of these benefits is modest at the individual level but significant at the population level.
Third, the evidence on mortality is less consistent. While the Adventist Health Study‑2 found a 12% reduction in all‑cause mortality for vegetarians, the EPIC‑Oxford cohort found no significant difference. This discrepancy likely reflects differences in study populations, diet quality, and the difficulty of controlling for lifestyle confounders. What is not disputed is that a high‑quality plant‑based diet – whether vegetarian, pescetarian, or flexitarian – is associated with lower mortality than a low‑quality diet, regardless of meat intake (Riera et al., 2025; Grammatikopoulou et al., 2025).
Fourth, the fatty acid profile of plant‑based diets is a double‑edged sword. Lower saturated fat and higher linoleic acid are favourable for cardiovascular risk, but the very low intake of long‑chain omega‑3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA) in vegetarian and especially vegan diets is a genuine concern. The omega‑3 index in vegans is substantially lower than in omnivores, and the conversion of plant‑based ALA to EPA and DHA is inefficient (Klein et al., 2025). Whether this translates into clinical harm in healthy young adults is unclear, but for vulnerable populations (pregnant women, infants, the elderly), ensuring adequate DHA intake – through microalgae supplements if necessary – is prudent.
Fifth, the gut microbiome carries a clear dietary signature. Omnivore microbiomes are enriched for species linked to meat fermentation and mucus degradation (Alistipes putredinis, Bilophila wadsworthia, Ruminococcus torques), while vegetarian and vegan microbiomes are enriched for butyrate producers (Lachnospiraceae, Roseburia hominis, Butyricicoccus). Dairy consumers harbour lactic acid bacteria from fermented products, and vegans show a surprising prevalence of soil‑associated environmental bacteria – an intriguing finding whose health implications are not yet understood (Fackelmann et al., 2025).
Sixth, affordability matters. In high‑income countries, the least‑cost nutritionally adequate diet includes animal foods (milk, eggs, fish). Excluding all animal foods increases diet cost by 34–45% and requires reliance on fortified products. For the nearly 20% of the world’s population for whom even the EAT‑Lancet diet is unaffordable, promoting strict plant‑based diets without ensuring access to fortified foods or supplements could worsen nutritional deficiencies (Chungchunlam & Moughan, 2024).
Seventh, the comparison between vegetarian and Western diets is not a simple binary. A high‑quality vegetarian diet is clearly superior to a typical Western diet. But a low‑quality vegetarian diet offers little advantage, and a high‑quality omnivorous diet (e.g., Mediterranean or flexitarian) can be just as beneficial as a high‑quality vegetarian diet. The focus should shift from excluding animal products to including a wide variety of minimally processed, nutrient‑dense plant foods – while reducing or eliminating red and processed meat, refined grains, and sugary products.
A note of caution
This article is intended for educational purposes only. It summarises observational and experimental research on population averages and associations. It does not provide medical advice, dietary prescriptions, or recommendations for individual treatment.
Human nutrition is highly individual. Genetic background, gut microbiome composition, lifestyle factors (physical activity, sleep, stress), socioeconomic circumstances, and pre‑existing health conditions all influence how a given diet affects a particular person. What works well for one individual – whether a vegetarian, vegan, or omnivore – may not work for another.
If you are considering a major dietary change, especially to a restrictive pattern such as vegetarianism or veganism, we strongly encourage you to consult a qualified healthcare professional – a registered dietitian, nutritionist, or physician. They can help assess your individual nutrient status, identify potential risks (e.g., vitamin B12, iron, calcium, omega‑3 status), and design a well‑planned diet that meets your specific needs. Self‑diagnosis of nutritional deficiencies or self‑prescription of restrictive diets without professional guidance carries risks, particularly for vulnerable groups (pregnant and lactating women, infants, children, adolescents, and the elderly).
The science of nutrition is complex and evolving. This article has aimed to present the evidence as objectively as possible, but no single review can capture all nuances or replace personalised professional advice. Use the information here to inform your understanding – not to diagnose, treat, or cure any condition.
Final remarks
Vegetarianism is not a magic bullet, nor is it a nutritional dead end. It is a legitimate and, when well‑planned, healthful dietary pattern that sits on a continuum of plant‑based eating. Its benefits depend critically on the quality of plant foods consumed, on attention to critical micronutrients (especially vitamin B12, iron, zinc, calcium, and omega‑3s), and on the overall lifestyle context.
For those who choose to follow a vegetarian diet, the evidence supports doing so with care: prioritise whole grains, legumes, vegetables, fruits, nuts, and seeds; minimise refined grains, sweets, and sugary drinks; ensure adequate vitamin B12 (through fortified foods or supplements); consider algae‑based DHA supplements; and, if possible, include some dairy and eggs (for lacto‑ovo‑vegetarians) or fish (for pescetarians) to improve nutrient adequacy and diet quality.
For those who choose to remain omnivorous, the evidence is equally clear: reducing red and processed meat, increasing whole plant foods, and following a Mediterranean‑style pattern confers health benefits that may rival those of vegetarianism.
The most important message, however, transcends the vegetarian‑versus‑omnivore debate: eat more plants, eat fewer highly processed foods, and pay attention to the quality of what you eat – regardless of the label you put on your diet. This simple principle is supported by decades of research and is consistent across dietary patterns, cultures, and economic contexts.
References
- Aydoğdu, G.S. and Karadağ, M.G. (2025) 'The two dimensions of nutrition for the planet: environment and health', Current Nutrition Reports, 14, 49. doi: 10.1007/s13668-025-00642-3.
- Bruns, A., Greupner, T., Nebl, J. and Hahn, A. (2024) 'Plant-based diets and cardiovascular risk factors: a comparison of flexitarians, vegans and omnivores in a cross-sectional study', BMC Nutrition, 10. doi: 10.1186/s40795-024-00839-9.
- Chungchunlam, S.M.S. and Moughan, P.J. (2024) 'Diet affordability: a key dimension in the assessment of sustainable food systems and healthy diets', Frontiers in Nutrition, 11, 1399109. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2024.1399109.
- Fackelmann, G., Manghi, P., Carlino, N., Heidrich, V., Piccinno, G., Ricci, L., Piperni, E., Arre, A., Bakker, E., Creedon, A.C., Francis, L., Pujol, J.C., Davies, R., Wolf, J., Bermingham, K.M., Berry, S.E., Spector, T.D., Asnicar, F. and Segata, N. (2025) 'Gut microbiome signatures of vegan, vegetarian and omnivore diets and associated health outcomes across 21,561 individuals', Nature Microbiology, 10, pp. 41–52. doi: 10.1038/s41564-024-01870-z.
- Grammatikopoulou, M.G., Gkouskou, K.K., Gkouvi, A., Bogdanos, D.P., Lambrinoudaki, I. and Goulis, D.G. (2025) 'Vegetarian diets for longevity: friend or foe?', Maturitas, 202, 108711. doi: 10.1016/j.maturitas.2025.108711.
- Klein, L., Lenz, C., Krüger, K., Lorkowski, S., Kipp, K. and Dawczynski, C. (2025) 'Comparative analysis of fatty acid profiles across omnivorous, flexitarians, vegetarians, and vegans: insights from the NuEva study', Lipids in Health and Disease, 24, 133. doi: 10.1186/s12944-025-02517-6.
- Leite, J.C., Caldeira, S., Watzl, B. and Wollgast, J. (2020) 'Healthy low nitrogen footprint diets', Global Food Security, 24, 100342. doi: 10.1016/j.gfs.2019.100342.
- Orlich, M.J. and Fraser, G.E. (2014) 'Vegetarian diets in the Adventist Health Study 2: a review of initial published findings', American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 100(suppl), pp. 353S–358S. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.113.071233.
- Riera, M.C.A., Ortolá, R., Kales, S.N., Graciani, A., Díaz‑Gutierrez, J., Banegas, J.R., Rodríguez‑Artalejo, F. and Sotos‑Prieto, M. (2025) 'Health and environmental dietary impact: Planetary health diet vs. Mediterranean diet. A nationwide cohort in Spain', Science of the Total Environment, 178924. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2025.178924.
- Rolands, M.R., Hackl, L.S., Bochud, M. and Le, K.A. (2025) 'Protein adequacy, plant protein proportion, and main plant protein sources consumed across vegan, vegetarian, pescovegetarian, and semivegetarian diets: a systematic review', The Journal of Nutrition, 155, pp. 153–167. doi: 10.1016/j.tjnut.2024.07.033.
- Rosenfeld, R.M., Juszczak, H.M. and Wong, M.A. (2023) 'Scoping review of the association of plant‑based diet quality with health outcomes', Frontiers in Nutrition, 10, 1211535. doi: 10.3389/fnut.2023.1211535.
- Sandri, E., Sguanci, M., Cantin Larumbe, E., Cerda Olmedo, G., Werner, L.U., Piredda, M. and Mancin, S. (2024) 'Plant‑based diets versus the Mediterranean dietary pattern and their socio‑demographic determinants in the Spanish population: influence on health and lifestyle habits', Nutrients, 16, 1278. doi: 10.3390/nu16091278.
- Segovia‑Siapco, G. and Sabaté, J. (2018) 'Health and sustainability outcomes of vegetarian dietary patterns: a revisit of the EPIC‑Oxford and the Adventist Health Study‑2 cohorts', European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 72, pp. 60–70. doi: 10.1038/s41430-018-0310-z.
